Search Results
Search type | Search syntax |
---|---|
Tags | [tag] |
Exact | "words here" |
Author |
user:1234 user:me (yours) |
Score |
score:3 (3+) score:0 (none) |
Answers |
answers:3 (3+) answers:0 (none) isaccepted:yes hasaccepted:no inquestion:1234 |
Views | views:250 |
Code | code:"if (foo != bar)" |
Sections |
title:apples body:"apples oranges" |
URL | url:"*.example.com" |
Saves | in:saves |
Status |
closed:yes duplicate:no migrated:no wiki:no |
Types |
is:question is:answer |
Exclude |
-[tag] -apples |
For more details on advanced search visit our help page |
History and philosophy of mathematics, biographies of mathematicians, mathematics education, recreational mathematics, communication of mathematics.
194
votes
Thinking and Explaining
I find there is a world of difference between explaining things to a colleague, and explaining things to a close collaborator. With the latter, one really can communicate at the intuitive level, beca …
141
votes
Accepted
Is the boundary $\partial S$ analogous to a derivative?
The surface area $|\partial S|$ of a (bounded, smooth) body $S$ is the derivative of the volume $|S_r|$ of the $r$-neighbourhoods $S_r$ of $S$ at $r=0$:
$$ |\partial S| = \frac{d}{dr} |S_r| |_{r=0}.$ …
86
votes
Mathematical habits of thought and action which would be of use to non-mathematicians
Here are some that came to mind:
Equivalence. Basically, the idea that two things can be functionally equivalent (or close to equivalent) even if they look very different (and conversely, that two t …
62
votes
Analogues of P vs. NP in the history of mathematics
This isn't an exact analogue to P != NP, in which two large classes exist and it is undecided whether they are equal or not; instead, two large "universes" exist, of which only one is the truth, with …
60
votes
The half-life of a theorem, or Arnold's principle at work
If $p$ is a prime, then every minor of the Fourier matrix $(e^{2\pi i jk/p})_{1 \leq j,k \leq p}$ is non-singular.
This fact was proven by Chebotarev in 1927 (answering a question of Ostrowski), Dani …
46
votes
Accepted
Does any research mathematics involve solving functional equations?
In additive combinatorics, one often seeks to count patterns such as an arithmetic progression $a, a+r, \ldots, a+(k-1)r$. When doing so, one is naturally led to expressions such as
$$ {\bf E}_{a,r \ …
40
votes
Taking a theorem as a definition and proving the original definition as a theorem
Many of the standard abstract mathematical structures were first defined and studied "externally" (in terms of some sort of concrete representation) and only later defined "internally" (as abstract sp …
34
votes
Accepted
Where did the term "additive energy" originate?
Van Vu and I coined the term in our book because there did not seem to be a widely adopted name for it previously. (Gowers, for instance, refers to "number of additive quadruples" rather than "additi …
34
votes
Proofs that require fundamentally new ways of thinking
It seems that certain problems seem to induce this sort of new thinking (cf. my article "What is good mathematics?"). You mentioned the Fourier-analytic proof of Roth's theorem; but in fact many of t …
27
votes
Why do we teach calculus students the derivative as a limit?
I wanted to add one further point to the many good answers already given here: "black box" symbolic computation, in the absence of understanding the formal definitions, can work when everything goes r …
26
votes
Examples of conjectures that were widely believed to be true but later proved false
I believe that Fefferman's disproof in 1971 of the $L^p$ boundedness of disc multiplier for any $p \neq 2$ was considered a great surprise at the time; it showed that the classical result of Bochner a …
22
votes
Examples of "unsuccessful" theories with afterlives
(Converted from a comment to an answer as requested.)
Non-Euclidean geometry was initially developed in hopes of deriving the parallel postulate from the other axioms of Euclidean geometry, as can be …
19
votes
Why are smooth numbers called "smooth"?
This is almost certainly not the historical justification for the term "smooth", but I have found that the term happily coincides with my analytic intuition of smoothness. Namely, I think of a scalar …
19
votes
Trichotomies in mathematics
After passing to a subsequence if necessary, a sequence of real numbers either (a) converges to a real number; (b) diverges to $+\infty$; or (c) diverges to $-\infty$. In a similar vein, a sequence …
18
votes
Proof by `universal receiver'
Lie's third theorem - that every finite-dimensional Lie algebra (over the reals) is the tangent space of some Lie group - is quite difficult to establish without first establishing Ado's theorem that …