Skip to main content
Added links
Source Link
Timothy Chow
  • 82.7k
  • 26
  • 363
  • 587

In a recent (unfortunately over-hyped) preprint by Saha and Sinha, Field theory expansions of string theory amplitudes (arXiv:2401.05733), they present the following series for $\pi$: $$\pi = 4 + \sum_{n=1}^\infty {1\over n!} \biggl({1\over n+\lambda} - {4\over 2n+1}\biggr)\biggl({(2n+1)^2 \over 4(n+\lambda)} - n \biggr)_{n-1},$$ where $\lambda$ is an arbitrary complex number and the Pochhammer symbol $(x)_n := x(x+1)\cdots(x+n-1)$.

Setting aside the unfortunate press coverage, as well as the question of the significance of this formula for $\pi$, what I'm wondering is whether it is new. The authors are physicists, and searching the literature for this type of thing is not always easy, so I figured that MathOverflow would be a natural place to ask.

A related, and perhaps easier, question is whether there are other known series for $\pi$ that involve a complex parameter $\lambda$ in the summand, but where the sum of the series is independent of the value of the parameter.


EDIT: Aninda Sinha asked essentially the same question on math.SE on March 8, 2024. See also the Numberphile interview of Sinha and Saha.

In a recent (unfortunately over-hyped) preprint by Saha and Sinha, Field theory expansions of string theory amplitudes (arXiv:2401.05733), they present the following series for $\pi$: $$\pi = 4 + \sum_{n=1}^\infty {1\over n!} \biggl({1\over n+\lambda} - {4\over 2n+1}\biggr)\biggl({(2n+1)^2 \over 4(n+\lambda)} - n \biggr)_{n-1},$$ where $\lambda$ is an arbitrary complex number and the Pochhammer symbol $(x)_n := x(x+1)\cdots(x+n-1)$.

Setting aside the unfortunate press coverage, as well as the question of the significance of this formula for $\pi$, what I'm wondering is whether it is new. The authors are physicists, and searching the literature for this type of thing is not always easy, so I figured that MathOverflow would be a natural place to ask.

A related, and perhaps easier, question is whether there are other known series for $\pi$ that involve a complex parameter $\lambda$ in the summand, but where the sum of the series is independent of the value of the parameter.

In a recent (unfortunately over-hyped) preprint by Saha and Sinha, Field theory expansions of string theory amplitudes (arXiv:2401.05733), they present the following series for $\pi$: $$\pi = 4 + \sum_{n=1}^\infty {1\over n!} \biggl({1\over n+\lambda} - {4\over 2n+1}\biggr)\biggl({(2n+1)^2 \over 4(n+\lambda)} - n \biggr)_{n-1},$$ where $\lambda$ is an arbitrary complex number and the Pochhammer symbol $(x)_n := x(x+1)\cdots(x+n-1)$.

Setting aside the unfortunate press coverage, as well as the question of the significance of this formula for $\pi$, what I'm wondering is whether it is new. The authors are physicists, and searching the literature for this type of thing is not always easy, so I figured that MathOverflow would be a natural place to ask.

A related, and perhaps easier, question is whether there are other known series for $\pi$ that involve a complex parameter $\lambda$ in the summand, but where the sum of the series is independent of the value of the parameter.


EDIT: Aninda Sinha asked essentially the same question on math.SE on March 8, 2024. See also the Numberphile interview of Sinha and Saha.
Notice removed Authoritative reference needed by Asaf Karagila
Notice added Authoritative reference needed by TheSimpliFire
Question Protected by Stefan Kohl
Add tag reference-request, since the main question is whether it's new
Link
Peter Taylor
  • 7.2k
  • 1
  • 21
  • 29
Source Link
Timothy Chow
  • 82.7k
  • 26
  • 363
  • 587

Possible new series for $\pi$

In a recent (unfortunately over-hyped) preprint by Saha and Sinha, Field theory expansions of string theory amplitudes (arXiv:2401.05733), they present the following series for $\pi$: $$\pi = 4 + \sum_{n=1}^\infty {1\over n!} \biggl({1\over n+\lambda} - {4\over 2n+1}\biggr)\biggl({(2n+1)^2 \over 4(n+\lambda)} - n \biggr)_{n-1},$$ where $\lambda$ is an arbitrary complex number and the Pochhammer symbol $(x)_n := x(x+1)\cdots(x+n-1)$.

Setting aside the unfortunate press coverage, as well as the question of the significance of this formula for $\pi$, what I'm wondering is whether it is new. The authors are physicists, and searching the literature for this type of thing is not always easy, so I figured that MathOverflow would be a natural place to ask.

A related, and perhaps easier, question is whether there are other known series for $\pi$ that involve a complex parameter $\lambda$ in the summand, but where the sum of the series is independent of the value of the parameter.