3
$\begingroup$

The following theorem is well-known in the ordinary analysis textbook:

Theorem: Assume the function $f:U\to\Bbb R^n$ is Lipschitz continuous on an open set $U\subset\Bbb R^m$, then $f$ is almost everywhere differentiable on $U$.

My question:

Question: Assume the function $f:U\to\Bbb{R}^n$ is Lipschitz continuous on an open set $U\subset\Bbb R^m$. Prove or disprove that $f$ is almost everywhere $C^1$ on $U$.

Basically, this means that the point where $f$ is not differentiable would be a zero-measure closed set and on the open set where $f$ is differentiable, the gradient should be continuous. Is there any counterexample?


Thank for all the comments. This problem is solved now. The key point is that there exists a function $f$ which is differentiable everywhere with bounded derivative but the set consisting of discontinuous point of $f'$ can have positive measure. See Differentiable function with discontinuous derivative

$\endgroup$
2
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ You can easily find counterexamples in the case $n=m=1$; here $f'$ may be (a.e.) any $L^\infty$ function. $\endgroup$ Mar 8 at 9:34
  • $\begingroup$ there exists a function $f$ which is differentiable everywhere with bounded derivative but the set consisting of discontinuous point of $f'$ can have positive measure --- The discontinuity set of $f'$ can even have full measure, meaning that the continuity set has measure zero. In fact, most functions with a bounded derivative ("most" in a Baire category sense) are such that their continuity sets have Hausdorff dimension zero (and even this can be strengthened by using gauge functions). $\endgroup$ Mar 8 at 20:39

1 Answer 1

7
$\begingroup$

The best thing you can do is the following: for every $\epsilon > 0$ there exists a $C^1$ function $g: U \to \mathbf{R}^n$ so that \begin{equation} \mathcal{H}^m(\{ f \neq g \} \cup \{ Df \neq Dg \} ) < \epsilon. \end{equation} This can be deduced from the Whitney extension theorem; you can find a proof in Leon Simon's lecture notes on GMT (Theorem 5.3, pp. 32-33).

Edit. It looks like I misread your question, sorry about that. Here is how to adapt the counterexample.

Let $C \subset [0,1]$ be a fat Cantor set. This is closed, has empty interior, and measure $\lambda := \mathcal{H}^1(C) \in (0,1)$. Define $f: x \mapsto \int_0^x \mathbf{1}_C$. This is $1$-Lipschitz and has $f(1) = \lambda$; moreover $f' = 0$ on the open complement $C^c$.

Now, if there were an open set $U \subset [0,1]$ of full measure, and along which $f$ is $C^1$, then $f' = 0$ on $U$, because $C$ has empty interior. But then on the one hand $\int_{[0,1]} f' = \int_{[0,1] \cap U} f' = 0$, and on the other hand $\int_{[0,1]} f' = f(1) - f(0) > 0$; this is absurd.

$\endgroup$
5
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks! The theorem you mentioned in Leon Simon's note is very interesting. But I think finding a $C^1$ function $g$ which agrees with $f$ almost everywhere seems to be much stronger than what I asked. To be more precise, consider the function $f(x)=|x|$ on $\mathbb{R}$. We directly see that $f$ is of $C^1$ on the open set $\mathbb{R}\backslash 0$, but of course one can not find any $C^1$ function $g$ which agrees with $f$ almost everywhere, because this actually requires $g=f$ everywhere. $\endgroup$ Mar 8 at 11:12
  • $\begingroup$ Yeah, the $\epsilon$ argument follows from the standard Littlewood's three principles in real analysis. I missed it. $\endgroup$ Mar 8 at 11:17
  • $\begingroup$ Solved now. The key point is that there exists a function which is differentiable everywhere with bounded gradient but whose point of discontinuity has positive measure. $\endgroup$ Mar 8 at 11:27
  • $\begingroup$ @WenqingOuyang You're completely right - I'd misread your question. Sorry about that! The counterexample also works for what you'd actually asked, though, and I've amended it to reflect this. $\endgroup$
    – Leo Moos
    Mar 8 at 11:37
  • $\begingroup$ Yes. I think you are correct. $\endgroup$ Mar 8 at 11:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.