For a Noetherian scheme $X$, let $D^b(X)$ denote the bounded derived category of coherent sheaves on $X$.
Let $X$ be a Noetherian scheme, $i:Y \hookrightarrow X$ a closed subscheme and $F$ an object of $D^b(Y)$. Is any object $G$ of $D^b(X)$ which is a direct summand of $i_*(F)$ isomorphic to $i_*(F')$ for some object $F'$ of $D^b(Y)$?
It is easy to find examples where $F'$ cannot be a direct summand of $F$, but I have not been able to find a counterexample to the above statement. I am mostly interested in the case that $X$ is a variety over some field and $Y$ is reduced, but this might not be the natural setting.
If the question has a positive answer (perhaps with some extra conditions on $X$ and $Y$) then I would also be interested in knowing the answer to the question with $D^b(X)$ replaced by other flavours of the derived category, e.g., $D^-(X)$, the derived category of quasicoherent sheaves,...