Skip to main content
Notice removed Draw attention by TheSimpliFire
Bounty Ended with Mostafa Ayaz's answer chosen by TheSimpliFire
Notice added Draw attention by TheSimpliFire
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by TheSimpliFire
added 2 characters in body
Source Link
TheSimpliFire
  • 1.5k
  • 14
  • 36

This is a follow-up of the question Dividing a spherical cap into three equal wedges where the $n=3$ case was shown.

Motivation: Optimal ways to cut an orange.

In this problem, we have a spherical orange of radius $R$, and we do not wish to eat its central column which is modelled as a cylinder of radius $r>0$. Part of the procedure involves an initial cut down the orange tangential to the central column, which produces a spherical cap, then further splitting the cap into $n$ wedges where each cut passes through the midpoint of the initial cut. The goal is to make these $n$ wedges have equal volumes.

The question is whether each of these $n$ wedges can have the same angle. A negative answer has been shown for the $n=3$ case, by deriving closed-form expressions for each volume and proving that they are incompatible with $\alpha_1=\alpha_2=\alpha_3=\pi/3$ and $V_1+V_2+V_3=\pi(R-r)^2(2R+r)/3$, which is the volume of the whole spherical cap.

Can this result be extended to $n$$n>3$ wedges of identical volume with angle $\pi/n$?

This is a follow-up of the question Dividing a spherical cap into three equal wedges where the $n=3$ case was shown.

Motivation: Optimal ways to cut an orange.

In this problem, we have a spherical orange of radius $R$, and we do not wish to eat its central column which is modelled as a cylinder of radius $r>0$. Part of the procedure involves an initial cut down the orange tangential to the central column, which produces a spherical cap, then further splitting the cap into $n$ wedges where each cut passes through the midpoint of the initial cut. The goal is to make these $n$ wedges have equal volumes.

The question is whether each of these $n$ wedges can have the same angle. A negative answer has been shown for the $n=3$ case, by deriving closed-form expressions for each volume and proving that they are incompatible with $\alpha_1=\alpha_2=\alpha_3=\pi/3$ and $V_1+V_2+V_3=\pi(R-r)^2(2R+r)/3$, which is the volume of the whole spherical cap.

Can this result be extended to $n$ wedges of identical volume with angle $\pi/n$?

This is a follow-up of the question Dividing a spherical cap into three equal wedges where the $n=3$ case was shown.

Motivation: Optimal ways to cut an orange.

In this problem, we have a spherical orange of radius $R$, and we do not wish to eat its central column which is modelled as a cylinder of radius $r>0$. Part of the procedure involves an initial cut down the orange tangential to the central column, which produces a spherical cap, then further splitting the cap into $n$ wedges where each cut passes through the midpoint of the initial cut. The goal is to make these $n$ wedges have equal volumes.

The question is whether each of these $n$ wedges can have the same angle. A negative answer has been shown for the $n=3$ case, by deriving closed-form expressions for each volume and proving that they are incompatible with $\alpha_1=\alpha_2=\alpha_3=\pi/3$ and $V_1+V_2+V_3=\pi(R-r)^2(2R+r)/3$, which is the volume of the whole spherical cap.

Can this result be extended to $n>3$ wedges of identical volume with angle $\pi/n$?

edited tags
Link
YCor
  • 63.9k
  • 5
  • 187
  • 286
Source Link
TheSimpliFire
  • 1.5k
  • 14
  • 36

Dividing a spherical cap into $n$ equal wedges

This is a follow-up of the question Dividing a spherical cap into three equal wedges where the $n=3$ case was shown.

Motivation: Optimal ways to cut an orange.

In this problem, we have a spherical orange of radius $R$, and we do not wish to eat its central column which is modelled as a cylinder of radius $r>0$. Part of the procedure involves an initial cut down the orange tangential to the central column, which produces a spherical cap, then further splitting the cap into $n$ wedges where each cut passes through the midpoint of the initial cut. The goal is to make these $n$ wedges have equal volumes.

The question is whether each of these $n$ wedges can have the same angle. A negative answer has been shown for the $n=3$ case, by deriving closed-form expressions for each volume and proving that they are incompatible with $\alpha_1=\alpha_2=\alpha_3=\pi/3$ and $V_1+V_2+V_3=\pi(R-r)^2(2R+r)/3$, which is the volume of the whole spherical cap.

Can this result be extended to $n$ wedges of identical volume with angle $\pi/n$?