Skip to main content
replaced http://mathoverflow.net/ with https://mathoverflow.net/
Source Link

This is raised by a recent question occurring in combinatorial geometrya recent question occurring in combinatorial geometry. It is about a sort of tractrix, but instead of a line, the pulling end moves along a circle of radius $r>\frac12$ (typically around $0.8$), starting with a chord if length 1. Imagine this chord horizontally on the bottom and take its center as the origine of a cartesian coordinate system. If the circle has center $(0,h)$, we have $h^2+\frac14=r^2$, so only one of $h$ and $r$ is needed to define the tractrix.
enter image description here

The tractrix is approximately the green line in the picture, where all blue segments (the tangents) have unit length.
Here is what I have got so far :

For a point $(x,y)$ on the tractrix where it has slope $f’$, we have 3 equations for the point $(u,v)$ where the tangent intersects the circle on the right:
$(i)\ \ \ \ v-y=(u-x)f’\ $ (equation of the tangent)
$(ii) \ \ \ u^2+(h-v)^2=r^2\ $ (intersection with the circle), equivalently $u^2+v^2-2hv-\frac14=0$. $(iii)\ \ (u-x)^2+(v-y)^2=1\ $ (constant length of the tangent between tractrix and circle).

Eliminating $u$ and $v$ yields the following differential equation for the tractrix: $$x+\sqrt{1-s^2}=\sqrt{2h(y+s)-(y+s)^2-\frac14}$$ where $$s :=\frac{f'}{\sqrt{1+f’^2}}.$$ (Thus $s$ is the sine of the slope angle.)

I don’t think there is a closed form of the tractrix equation. But is there a way to determine at which point $(x,y)$ the tangent is vertical? I'd expect it to be a not-too-involved function of $h$.

Note that, unless $r$ is too small for reaching the vertical position at all, the tractrix will carry on winding beyond the vertical for a finite time. That is, under the assumption that at each moment, the segment is tangent to the tractrix at its (the segment's) endpoint. (Imagine $r$ a bit smaller than in the picture, such that the vertical tangent of the tractrix coincides with the $y$-axis. From there on, the top of the blue segment cannot move further to the left without "breaking the smoothness" of the tractrix. I think that for each $r$, the movement will eventually arrive at such a point, which we will naturally consider as the endpoint of the tractrix.)

But where is that point? I have no idea how far it can go if $r$ is big, but I don't think it will go further than becoming horizontal again. All this is easier to perceive if we keep $r$ constant and require the 'rotating' segment of length $\epsilon$ instead of unit length. So:

Where does the tractrix stop if $\epsilon\to0$?

This is raised by a recent question occurring in combinatorial geometry. It is about a sort of tractrix, but instead of a line, the pulling end moves along a circle of radius $r>\frac12$ (typically around $0.8$), starting with a chord if length 1. Imagine this chord horizontally on the bottom and take its center as the origine of a cartesian coordinate system. If the circle has center $(0,h)$, we have $h^2+\frac14=r^2$, so only one of $h$ and $r$ is needed to define the tractrix.
enter image description here

The tractrix is approximately the green line in the picture, where all blue segments (the tangents) have unit length.
Here is what I have got so far :

For a point $(x,y)$ on the tractrix where it has slope $f’$, we have 3 equations for the point $(u,v)$ where the tangent intersects the circle on the right:
$(i)\ \ \ \ v-y=(u-x)f’\ $ (equation of the tangent)
$(ii) \ \ \ u^2+(h-v)^2=r^2\ $ (intersection with the circle), equivalently $u^2+v^2-2hv-\frac14=0$. $(iii)\ \ (u-x)^2+(v-y)^2=1\ $ (constant length of the tangent between tractrix and circle).

Eliminating $u$ and $v$ yields the following differential equation for the tractrix: $$x+\sqrt{1-s^2}=\sqrt{2h(y+s)-(y+s)^2-\frac14}$$ where $$s :=\frac{f'}{\sqrt{1+f’^2}}.$$ (Thus $s$ is the sine of the slope angle.)

I don’t think there is a closed form of the tractrix equation. But is there a way to determine at which point $(x,y)$ the tangent is vertical? I'd expect it to be a not-too-involved function of $h$.

Note that, unless $r$ is too small for reaching the vertical position at all, the tractrix will carry on winding beyond the vertical for a finite time. That is, under the assumption that at each moment, the segment is tangent to the tractrix at its (the segment's) endpoint. (Imagine $r$ a bit smaller than in the picture, such that the vertical tangent of the tractrix coincides with the $y$-axis. From there on, the top of the blue segment cannot move further to the left without "breaking the smoothness" of the tractrix. I think that for each $r$, the movement will eventually arrive at such a point, which we will naturally consider as the endpoint of the tractrix.)

But where is that point? I have no idea how far it can go if $r$ is big, but I don't think it will go further than becoming horizontal again. All this is easier to perceive if we keep $r$ constant and require the 'rotating' segment of length $\epsilon$ instead of unit length. So:

Where does the tractrix stop if $\epsilon\to0$?

This is raised by a recent question occurring in combinatorial geometry. It is about a sort of tractrix, but instead of a line, the pulling end moves along a circle of radius $r>\frac12$ (typically around $0.8$), starting with a chord if length 1. Imagine this chord horizontally on the bottom and take its center as the origine of a cartesian coordinate system. If the circle has center $(0,h)$, we have $h^2+\frac14=r^2$, so only one of $h$ and $r$ is needed to define the tractrix.
enter image description here

The tractrix is approximately the green line in the picture, where all blue segments (the tangents) have unit length.
Here is what I have got so far :

For a point $(x,y)$ on the tractrix where it has slope $f’$, we have 3 equations for the point $(u,v)$ where the tangent intersects the circle on the right:
$(i)\ \ \ \ v-y=(u-x)f’\ $ (equation of the tangent)
$(ii) \ \ \ u^2+(h-v)^2=r^2\ $ (intersection with the circle), equivalently $u^2+v^2-2hv-\frac14=0$. $(iii)\ \ (u-x)^2+(v-y)^2=1\ $ (constant length of the tangent between tractrix and circle).

Eliminating $u$ and $v$ yields the following differential equation for the tractrix: $$x+\sqrt{1-s^2}=\sqrt{2h(y+s)-(y+s)^2-\frac14}$$ where $$s :=\frac{f'}{\sqrt{1+f’^2}}.$$ (Thus $s$ is the sine of the slope angle.)

I don’t think there is a closed form of the tractrix equation. But is there a way to determine at which point $(x,y)$ the tangent is vertical? I'd expect it to be a not-too-involved function of $h$.

Note that, unless $r$ is too small for reaching the vertical position at all, the tractrix will carry on winding beyond the vertical for a finite time. That is, under the assumption that at each moment, the segment is tangent to the tractrix at its (the segment's) endpoint. (Imagine $r$ a bit smaller than in the picture, such that the vertical tangent of the tractrix coincides with the $y$-axis. From there on, the top of the blue segment cannot move further to the left without "breaking the smoothness" of the tractrix. I think that for each $r$, the movement will eventually arrive at such a point, which we will naturally consider as the endpoint of the tractrix.)

But where is that point? I have no idea how far it can go if $r$ is big, but I don't think it will go further than becoming horizontal again. All this is easier to perceive if we keep $r$ constant and require the 'rotating' segment of length $\epsilon$ instead of unit length. So:

Where does the tractrix stop if $\epsilon\to0$?

Source Link
Wolfgang
  • 13.4k
  • 5
  • 45
  • 102

A tricky tractrix question about vertical tangents

This is raised by a recent question occurring in combinatorial geometry. It is about a sort of tractrix, but instead of a line, the pulling end moves along a circle of radius $r>\frac12$ (typically around $0.8$), starting with a chord if length 1. Imagine this chord horizontally on the bottom and take its center as the origine of a cartesian coordinate system. If the circle has center $(0,h)$, we have $h^2+\frac14=r^2$, so only one of $h$ and $r$ is needed to define the tractrix.
enter image description here

The tractrix is approximately the green line in the picture, where all blue segments (the tangents) have unit length.
Here is what I have got so far :

For a point $(x,y)$ on the tractrix where it has slope $f’$, we have 3 equations for the point $(u,v)$ where the tangent intersects the circle on the right:
$(i)\ \ \ \ v-y=(u-x)f’\ $ (equation of the tangent)
$(ii) \ \ \ u^2+(h-v)^2=r^2\ $ (intersection with the circle), equivalently $u^2+v^2-2hv-\frac14=0$. $(iii)\ \ (u-x)^2+(v-y)^2=1\ $ (constant length of the tangent between tractrix and circle).

Eliminating $u$ and $v$ yields the following differential equation for the tractrix: $$x+\sqrt{1-s^2}=\sqrt{2h(y+s)-(y+s)^2-\frac14}$$ where $$s :=\frac{f'}{\sqrt{1+f’^2}}.$$ (Thus $s$ is the sine of the slope angle.)

I don’t think there is a closed form of the tractrix equation. But is there a way to determine at which point $(x,y)$ the tangent is vertical? I'd expect it to be a not-too-involved function of $h$.

Note that, unless $r$ is too small for reaching the vertical position at all, the tractrix will carry on winding beyond the vertical for a finite time. That is, under the assumption that at each moment, the segment is tangent to the tractrix at its (the segment's) endpoint. (Imagine $r$ a bit smaller than in the picture, such that the vertical tangent of the tractrix coincides with the $y$-axis. From there on, the top of the blue segment cannot move further to the left without "breaking the smoothness" of the tractrix. I think that for each $r$, the movement will eventually arrive at such a point, which we will naturally consider as the endpoint of the tractrix.)

But where is that point? I have no idea how far it can go if $r$ is big, but I don't think it will go further than becoming horizontal again. All this is easier to perceive if we keep $r$ constant and require the 'rotating' segment of length $\epsilon$ instead of unit length. So:

Where does the tractrix stop if $\epsilon\to0$?