Skip to main content
Notice removed Draw attention by Peter Samuelson
Bounty Ended with Ian Agol's answer chosen by Peter Samuelson
Notice added Draw attention by Peter Samuelson
Bounty Started worth 100 reputation by Peter Samuelson
added additional tags
Link
Source Link

Does the limit in the Volume conjecture converge?

The Volume conjecture says that if $J_n(q)$ are the colored Jones polynomials of a knot $K \subset S^3$, then $$\lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{ 2 \pi}N \left\vert J_N(e^{2\pi i / N})\right\vert = vol(K)$$ Here we are assuming that the complement of $K$ is hyperbolic, and $vol(K)$ is its hyperbolic volume. (The normalization is that $J_N(q) = 1$ for the unknot.) I have an ignorant question about this:

Q: Is it obvious that this limit exists?

One thing that might be helpful for showing the limit exists is that the $J_n(q)$ satisfy a (generalized) recursion relation (this is a theorem of Garoufalidis and Le). More precisely, there are Laurent polynomials $a_i(-,-)$ such that $$ \sum_i a_i(q,q^N) J_{N+i}(q) = 0$$ (This is true for any $N$, and the $a_i$ don't depend on $N$.) But the existence of this recursion relation was proved several years after the volume conjecture.