Search Results
Search type | Search syntax |
---|---|
Tags | [tag] |
Exact | "words here" |
Author |
user:1234 user:me (yours) |
Score |
score:3 (3+) score:0 (none) |
Answers |
answers:3 (3+) answers:0 (none) isaccepted:yes hasaccepted:no inquestion:1234 |
Views | views:250 |
Code | code:"if (foo != bar)" |
Sections |
title:apples body:"apples oranges" |
URL | url:"*.example.com" |
Saves | in:saves |
Status |
closed:yes duplicate:no migrated:no wiki:no |
Types |
is:question is:answer |
Exclude |
-[tag] -apples |
For more details on advanced search visit our help page |
Questions about mathematical publishing, including specific journals, peer review etc.
7
votes
How bad is it to publish a paper with an overcomplicated proof?
This kind of situation is very common. In some sense, it's the nature of research. Consider the following quote from Andrew Wiles:
"Perhaps I could best describe my experience of doing mathematics in …
4
votes
Referring to computer software in a paper
Many journals now require this, e.g., I have had to make my code available in PLOS ONE, and in Crime Science. Other times, I chose to make my code available even if the journal did not require it. …
2
votes
Accepted
Including alternative proofs
slightly longer, which can make it take longer to publish (e.g., more time waiting for a referee report), can slightly raise the bar for publication (in the mind of the editor), and can rule out some journals …
7
votes
Accepted
Mathematical etiquette: Rephrasing / restructuring a work, limited release (with attribution...
This question was asked a long time ago, but remains on the unanswered queue. I agree with Allen Knutson's comment that this is good thing to do (i.e., write up such notes and post them on your webpag …
5
votes
Journal of serious opinions on weighty matters for mathematicians
This question was asked some time ago but remains on the unanswered queue. I want to echo Nate's comment regarding the Journal of Humanistic Mathematics. I've published two papers there. The first one …
5
votes
Is it appropriate to add a dedication to a paper?
In math, dedications are rare but not unheard of. They are most common in birthday conference proceedings, or special issues devoted to summarizing a person's life work. For example, consider the foll …
4
votes
Use of an appendix in a long paper
Pressures to keep papers short come from:
Journals, because there's often a higher bar for longer papers, because they take up more space in the issue. … It would also be smart to aim for journals that publish long papers and aim for electronic journals where length is less of a concern. …
12
votes
What would you do if you improve your own result that is submitted but not published?
Just get things submitted, give good talks, and do your best to bounce back from setbacks (e.g., resubmitting to lower journals if something gets rejected), and usually it all works out in the end, even …
1
vote
Math journals publishing in Spanish
Revista Integración: https://revistas.uis.edu.co/index.php/revistaintegracion
Revista Matemática Complutense: https://link.springer.com/journal/13163
Revista Matemática Iberoamericana: https://ems.press/journals … published in Spanish there: https://www.muni.cz/vyzkum/publikace/1168664
Scripta Philosophiæ Naturalis
Pensamiento Matemático
And, I think the best answer was the first comment, which gave a list of 50 journals …
4
votes
Accepted
Publication Of 50 pages
The short answer is there are hundreds of journals that would publish such a paper. In some fields of mathematics, 50 pages is a totally reasonable length. … I estimate fewer than 10% of journals have a page limit.
That said, it's also true that, all things being equal, longer papers are slightly harder to publish than shorter papers, for two reasons. …
9
votes
What are journal rankings that employers look at?
For example, at tenure time, if a candidate has more than six papers in good journals (where "good" is again assessed by general knowledge of journal landscape) then they are above the bar for research … There are also rankings from Norway and Finland but they include all journals in the sciences, and math journals are essentially always the bottom because we have a lower impact factor, because of how …
10
votes
Use of singular pronoun "I" in the acknowledgements
This question was asked some time ago, but never received an answer. It has several highly upvoted comments, but there is also disagreement in the comments. I think the question is reasonable, given t …
4
votes
How would you cite a result that it is not quite correct, but whose proof contains some usef...
This question was asked a long time ago, but never received an answer. I largely agree with Deane Yang's comment, but wish to expand on it, for the sake of future visitors to MO.
First, several other …
4
votes
Where can I publish a paper about how to write mathematical papers?
Whenever you write anything, including a paper on "How (not) to write a mathematical paper," it is wise to ask yourself who is my intended audience? That influences the choice of where to publish and …
4
votes
Refereeing a paper containing strong statements about other papers
I am surprised that this question never received an answer, though it did receive useful comments. My view is that a claim like "Theorem 1 in paper B is wrong" is a claim, just like any other in paper …