Skip to main content
4 of 9
added 106 characters in body
user avatar
user avatar

Construct a random vector as a function of another random vector

Consider a continuous random vector $(X,Y,Z)$ such that $$ \begin{cases} p_1=\Pr(X\geq 0, Z\geq 0)\\ p_2=\Pr(Y\geq 0, Z< 0)\\ p_3=\Pr(X< 0, Y<0)\\ \end{cases} $$ where $(p_1,p_2,p_3)\in [0,1]^3$ and $p_1+p_2+p_3=1$. Further, the marginal distribution of each of $X,Y,Z$ are symmetric around 0.

QUESTION: Can we construct from $(X,Y,Z)$ a continuous random vector $(W,H,Q)$ such that:

  1. it holds that $$ \begin{cases} \Pr(W\geq 0, Q\geq 0)=p_1\\ \Pr(H\geq 0, Q< 0)= p_2\\ \Pr(W< 0, H<0)= p_3\\ \end{cases} $$

  2. the marginal distribution of each of $W,H,Q$ are symmetric around 0.

  3. $Q=W-H$.

Note that the map from $(X,Y,Z)$ to $(W,H,Q)$ does not need to be deterministic. For instance, it could be that $W=X+\epsilon$ where $\epsilon$ is another well defined random variable.

SOME DISCUSSION ON THE MOTIVATION BEHIND THE QUESTION: I have a problem in statistics/computer science where I need to verify the existence of a 3-d distribution function that satisfies constraints 1-3. However, constraint 3 is computationally intractable to implement because infinite-dimensional. Much simpler is to verify the existence of a 3-d distribution function that satisfies constraints 1-2 and, then, use the construction I'm investigating about (if it exists!) to conclude about the existence of the originally desired distribution.

user447159