1
$\begingroup$

I am aware that the dual of $C^\infty(\mathbb{R}^n)$ is the space of distributions (not necessarily tempered) with compact support.

However, if we fix a compact set $K \subset \mathbb{R}^n$, is the space of distributions supported on $K$ the dual of some test function space?

If so, the test function space must be even larger than $C^\infty(\mathbb{R}^n)$, so I am a bit confused...

Could anyone please clarify?

$\endgroup$
0

3 Answers 3

2
$\begingroup$

A few reminders: [1] The dual space of $\mathscr D(\mathbb R^n)= C^\infty_c(\mathbb R^n)$ ($C^\infty$ functions with compact support) is $\mathscr D'(\mathbb R^n)$ (distributions on $\mathbb R^n$).

[2] The dual space of $\mathscr S(\mathbb R^n)$ ($C^\infty$ functions rapidly decreasing) is $\mathscr S'(\mathbb R^n)$ (temperate distributions on $\mathbb R^n$).

[3] The dual space of $\mathscr E(\mathbb R^n)=C^\infty(\mathbb R^n)$ ($C^\infty$ functions) is $\mathscr E'(\mathbb R^n)$ (compactly supported distributions on $\mathbb R^n$).

You have the continuous injections $ \mathscr D(\mathbb R^n)\subset \mathscr S(\mathbb R^n)\subset \mathscr E(\mathbb R^n) $ and thus $$ \mathscr D'(\mathbb R^n)\supset \mathscr S'(\mathbb R^n)\supset \mathscr E'(\mathbb R^n). $$ The only thing which is not obvious in the above statements is [3]: you have to prove that a continuous linear form on $\mathscr E(\mathbb R^n)$ has compact support. It is possible to prove that with the Paley-Wiener Theorem.

Now if you fix a compact set $K$ and consider $\mathscr D_K(\mathbb R^n)=C_K^\infty(\mathbb R^n)$, then the latter space is a Fréchet space (which is complete and metrizable); note that $\mathscr D(\mathbb R^n)$ is the inductive limit of the $\mathscr D_K(\mathbb R^n)$ and is not metrizable. If you want to consider $\mathscr E'_K(\mathbb R^n)$ (the distributions supported in $K$, assumed to be convex), then you have a characterization via the Paley-Wiener theorem: $u$ belongs to $\mathscr E'_K(\mathbb R^n)$ iff $\hat u$ can be extended to an entire function on $\mathbb C^n$ such that $$ \vert\hat u(\zeta)\vert\le C_0(1+\vert \zeta\vert)^{N_0} e^{2π I_K(\Im \zeta)}, $$ where $I_K$ is the so-called supporting function of $K$. So $\mathscr E'_K(\mathbb R^n)$ appears as a subspace of $\mathscr E'(\mathbb R^n)$ which is characterized by the behaviour of its Fourier transform and not as a dual space.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

The short answer to your question is yes. There is such a space, that of the locally smooth functions on $K$.

Let us recall that Schwartz defined the space of distributions with support in $K$ not directly by duality but by first defining the space of distributions on the line, then the notion of restriction of a distribution to an open set and finally the support of a distribution as the complement of the union of the open sets on which it vanishes. In parallel he defined the space of distributions of compact support as the dual of the Frechet space $C^\infty$ of smooth functions there. It is then a theorem that the two concepts coincide.

The answer to your question is rather more subtle. This can be seen in the simplest case, i.e., where $K$ is the origin in the real line. The space of distributions with support there is infinite dimensional--it consists of the linear combinations of the Dirac distribution and its derivatives. This can obviously not be the dual of a space of functions defined on a single point. It is, however, the dual of the space of germs of smooth functions at the origin, which is defined as the inductive of the spaces $C^\infty(]-\epsilon,\epsilon[)$ over positive $\epsilon$. As the parameter decreases to zero, these form an inductive system of Frechet spaces and its union can be given a lcs structure in the standard way as an inductive limit, i.e., provided with the finest such structure for which the corresponding injections are continuous. The dual of this space is then the space of distributions with support at the origin.

This can be extended to the general situation in the natural way. For a given compactum $K$ one considers the family {$C^\infty(U)$} of Frechet spaces indexed by the open neighbourhoods of $K$. This forms an inductive system and its inductive limit as above is by definition the space of functions which are locally smooth on $K$. Once again, its dual is the space of distributions with support in $K$. We remark that it is an abuse of notation to call these functions. They are in fact germs of functions, a concept familiar from differential topology. In order to avoid misunderstandings, I recall the definition: if $C$ is a closed set in a topological space, a germ of a function on $C$ is a pair $(f,U)$ where $U$ is an open neighbourhood of $C$ and $f$ is a function defined on $U$. Two such germs $(f,U)$ and $(f_1,U_1)$ are identified if there is an open neighbourhood $U_2$ of $C$ contained in $U\cap U_1$ on which they agree. In our case, we have a compact set in a manifold and we consider only infinitely smooth functions. This is a concrete representation of the set theoretical inductive limit of the above system and so has a natural lc structure by taking the limit in the sense of locally convex spaces. This is the formal definition of the space of functions on $K$ (more precisely, germs of functions on $K$) whose dual is the space of distributions with support in $K$.

As a final remark, this approach works smoothly in the context of complex analytic functions where it leads to the concept of the space of functions which are locally analytic on a closed subset of the complex plane. This was used by Köthe in his work on duality in spaces of holomorphic functions from the 50´s, extending work of J. Sebastiao e Silva for the disc.

$\endgroup$
1
  • $\begingroup$ To call the inductive system $X_\varepsilon=C^\infty({]}-\varepsilon,\varepsilon{[}$ increaing (if $\varepsilon$ decreases to $0$) is quite dangerous -- the restriction operators $X_\varepsilon\to X_\delta$ are not injective. The space $\mathscr E'(\{0\})$ is countable dimensional -- a predual must then be isomorphic to the Fréchet space $\mathbb C^{\mathbb N}$ of all sequences. $\endgroup$ Commented May 4, 2023 at 7:51
1
$\begingroup$

The space $\mathscr E'(K)$ of distributions with support in the comact set $K$ is a closed subspace of $\mathscr E'(\mathbb R^d)$ of all distributions with compact support, the latter space being the dual (with the topology of uniform convergence on all bounded sets) of $C^\infty(\mathbb R^d)$.

General locally convex theory then tells you that $\mathscr E'(K)$ is the dual of the quotient $\mathscr E(K)=C^\infty(\mathbb R^d)/I$ where $I$ turns out to the the space of smooth functions $f$ such that all derivatives $\partial^\alpha f$ vanish on $K$.

A priori, this is just some abstract space, but Whitney's extension theorem characterizes $\mathscr E(K)$ as the space of Whitney jets $(f^{(\alpha)})_{\alpha\in \mathbb N_0^d}$ which are families of continuous functions on $K$ whose formal Taylor series behave like the Taylor series of smooth functions on $\mathbb R^d$.

$\endgroup$

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .