An abstract polytope is a poset $X$ (here finite), whose elements are called faces, satisfying these 4 conditions:

  1. There is a least face and a greatest face.
  2. All flags (i.e. maximal chains) have the same number of faces.
  3. $X$ is strongly connected, i.e. for every interval $[F_1,F_2]$ in $X$ and $F, F' \in (F_1,F_2)$ there is a way to get from $F$ to $F'$ via adjacent faces in $(F_1,F_2)$.
  4. If $F_1 < F_2$ differ in rank by 2, then there are exactly two intermediate faces $F, F'$ in the interval $(F_1,F_2)$.

Denote the set of faces of rank $i$ in $X$ by $X_i$ and the rank of $X$ by $n$. My question is:

If $X$ is an abstract polytope with $\chi(X) = 0$, i.e. $\sum_{i=-1}^n (-1)^i X_i = 0$, then is $X$ necessarily Eulerian, i.e. is it the case that for every $F_1 < F_2$, $\sum_{i = rank(F_1)}^{rank(F_2)} (-1)^i[F_1,F_2]_i = 0$?

(Edit: the $X$'s I have in mind are lattices, i.e. any two distinct faces have a unique join [least upper bound] and meet [greatest lower bound].)


The answer is no. Let $Y$ be the face poset of a triangulation of a torus, with a top element $t$ adjoined. Let $\emptyset$ (the empty face) be the bottom element of $Y$. Let $Z$ be the chain $0<1$. Then the product $Y\times Z$ satisfies your conditions. However, the interval from $(\emptyset,0)$ to $(t,0)$ does not satisfy the Eulerian condition.

  • $\begingroup$ Sorry for this question, but I got confused. Although I have checked what you say, and everything is correct, I still don't understand one thing. Geometrically, $Y\times Z$ must be the cylinder of $Y$, so be homotopy equivalent to $Y$, hence have the same Euler characteristic. How come they are different?? $\endgroup$ – მამუკა ჯიბლაძე Feb 22 '17 at 7:21
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ They would have the same Euler characteristic if $Y$ were the face poset of a triangulation of the torus, but we have adjoined an extra element $t$. $\endgroup$ – Richard Stanley Feb 22 '17 at 14:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.