Skip to main content
edited tags
Link
mathphysicist
  • 5.3k
  • 1
  • 42
  • 44
restated questions, vagueness removed.
Source Link

Let $P$ be a polyhedron which satisfies the following three conditions:

  1. $P$ is built out of regular hexagons and regular pentagons.
  2. Three faces meet at each vertex.
  3. $P$ is topologically a sphere.

An easy Euler characteristic argument tells you that $P$ has exactly twelve pentagonal faces.

An example of a polyhedron like this is a soccertruncated icosahedron (soccer ball for those of us in the States, football for everyone else). In this case, the pentagonal faces are arranged with some nice symmetry, and the polyhedron has icosahedral symmetry.

Another (trivial) example is the regular dodecahedron, which again has some very niceicosahedral symmetry.

Here's my question: Is this symmetry forced? What, if anything, can be said in general about the symmetry of a polyhedron which satisfies the above three conditions?

Edit: Since the discussion below points out that there are precisely two polyhedra which satisfy the above conditions, a suitable evolution of the question, which has already begun to be discussed below, is this: What symmetry groups can a polyhedron have if one or more of the above conditions are relaxed?

Let $P$ be a polyhedron which satisfies the following three conditions:

  1. $P$ is built out of regular hexagons and regular pentagons.
  2. Three faces meet at each vertex.
  3. $P$ is topologically a sphere.

An easy Euler characteristic argument tells you that $P$ has exactly twelve pentagonal faces.

An example of a polyhedron like this is a soccer ball. In this case, the pentagonal faces are arranged with some nice symmetry.

Another (trivial) example is the regular dodecahedron, which again has some very nice symmetry.

Here's my question: Is this symmetry forced? What, if anything, can be said in general about the symmetry of a polyhedron which satisfies the above three conditions?

Let $P$ be a polyhedron which satisfies the following three conditions:

  1. $P$ is built out of regular hexagons and regular pentagons.
  2. Three faces meet at each vertex.
  3. $P$ is topologically a sphere.

An easy Euler characteristic argument tells you that $P$ has exactly twelve pentagonal faces.

An example of a polyhedron like this is a truncated icosahedron (soccer ball for those of us in the States, football for everyone else). In this case, the pentagonal faces are arranged with some nice symmetry, and the polyhedron has icosahedral symmetry.

Another (trivial) example is the regular dodecahedron, which again has icosahedral symmetry.

Here's my question: Is this symmetry forced? What, if anything, can be said in general about the symmetry of a polyhedron which satisfies the above three conditions?

Edit: Since the discussion below points out that there are precisely two polyhedra which satisfy the above conditions, a suitable evolution of the question, which has already begun to be discussed below, is this: What symmetry groups can a polyhedron have if one or more of the above conditions are relaxed?

Source Link

The Symmetry of a Soccer Ball

Let $P$ be a polyhedron which satisfies the following three conditions:

  1. $P$ is built out of regular hexagons and regular pentagons.
  2. Three faces meet at each vertex.
  3. $P$ is topologically a sphere.

An easy Euler characteristic argument tells you that $P$ has exactly twelve pentagonal faces.

An example of a polyhedron like this is a soccer ball. In this case, the pentagonal faces are arranged with some nice symmetry.

Another (trivial) example is the regular dodecahedron, which again has some very nice symmetry.

Here's my question: Is this symmetry forced? What, if anything, can be said in general about the symmetry of a polyhedron which satisfies the above three conditions?