Skip to main content
Some clarifications after comments of Mariano Suárez-Alvarez
Source Link
Salvo Tringali
  • 10.5k
  • 2
  • 29
  • 64

Let me start by recalling some basic definitions (just for the sake of avoiding misunderstandings due to the vocabulary of the post).

Basically following some ideas of W. Lawvere (but not his terminology), we let a semimetric on a set $X$ be a function $d: X \times X \to [0,\infty]$ such that $d(x,x) = 0$ and $d(x,z) \le d(x,y) + d(y,z)$ for all $x,y,z \in X$. Exactly as with "classical" metrics, $d$ induces a topology on $X$, which we call the canonical topology of $d$, having as a base the sets $\{y \in X: d(x,y) < r\}$ as $x$ ranges over $X$ and $r$ over $\mathbf R^+$.

Next, we take a topological monoid to be, as usual, a pair $(\mathbb M, \tau)$ consisting of a (multiplicatively written) monoid $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ and a topology $\tau$ on $M$ such that $\cdot$ is continuous [...] in the expected sense.

Finally, if $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ is a monoid and $d$ is a semimetric on $M$, we say that $d$ is: right subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if $d(xz,yz) \le d(x,y)$ for all $x,y,z \in M$; left subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is right subinvariant in the dual of $\mathbb M$; and subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is both right and left subinvariant.

With all of this in mind, what is known about the following question?

Let $(\mathbb M, \tau)$ be a topological monoid, with $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$. Does there always exist a left (respectively, right) subinvariant semimetric $d$ on $M$ such that $\tau$ is the canonical topology of $d$? And what about a subinvariant semimetric?

Edit (based on the comments below). I don't expect this to be true in general. I would be happy with something of the form: "The answer is known to be positive for all the members of $\mathcal C_1$, and negative for all the members of $\mathcal C_2$", where $\mathcal C_1$ and $\mathcal C_2$ are "non-trivial" classes of ("sufficiently small") topological monoids.

Thanks in advance for any possible pointer.

Let me start by recalling some basic definitions (just for the sake of avoiding misunderstandings due to the vocabulary of the post).

Basically following some ideas of W. Lawvere (but not his terminology), we let a semimetric on a set $X$ be a function $d: X \times X \to [0,\infty]$ such that $d(x,x) = 0$ and $d(x,z) \le d(x,y) + d(y,z)$ for all $x,y,z \in X$. Exactly as with "classical" metrics, $d$ induces a topology on $X$, which we call the canonical topology of $d$, having as a base the sets $\{y \in X: d(x,y) < r\}$ as $x$ ranges over $X$ and $r$ over $\mathbf R^+$.

Next, we take a topological monoid to be, as usual, a pair $(\mathbb M, \tau)$ consisting of a (multiplicatively written) monoid $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ and a topology $\tau$ on $M$ such that $\cdot$ is continuous [...] in the expected sense.

Finally, if $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ is a monoid and $d$ is a semimetric on $M$, we say that $d$ is: right subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if $d(xz,yz) \le d(x,y)$ for all $x,y,z \in M$; left subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is right subinvariant in the dual of $\mathbb M$; and subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is both right and left subinvariant.

With all of this in mind, what is known about the following question?

Let $(\mathbb M, \tau)$ be a topological monoid, with $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$. Does there always exist a left (respectively, right) subinvariant semimetric $d$ on $M$ such that $\tau$ is the canonical topology of $d$? And what about a subinvariant semimetric?

Thanks in advance for any possible pointer.

Let me start by recalling some basic definitions (just for the sake of avoiding misunderstandings due to the vocabulary of the post).

Basically following some ideas of W. Lawvere (but not his terminology), we let a semimetric on a set $X$ be a function $d: X \times X \to [0,\infty]$ such that $d(x,x) = 0$ and $d(x,z) \le d(x,y) + d(y,z)$ for all $x,y,z \in X$. Exactly as with "classical" metrics, $d$ induces a topology on $X$, which we call the canonical topology of $d$, having as a base the sets $\{y \in X: d(x,y) < r\}$ as $x$ ranges over $X$ and $r$ over $\mathbf R^+$.

Next, we take a topological monoid to be, as usual, a pair $(\mathbb M, \tau)$ consisting of a (multiplicatively written) monoid $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ and a topology $\tau$ on $M$ such that $\cdot$ is continuous [...] in the expected sense.

Finally, if $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ is a monoid and $d$ is a semimetric on $M$, we say that $d$ is: right subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if $d(xz,yz) \le d(x,y)$ for all $x,y,z \in M$; left subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is right subinvariant in the dual of $\mathbb M$; and subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is both right and left subinvariant.

With all of this in mind, what is known about the following question?

Let $(\mathbb M, \tau)$ be a topological monoid, with $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$. Does there always exist a left (respectively, right) subinvariant semimetric $d$ on $M$ such that $\tau$ is the canonical topology of $d$? And what about a subinvariant semimetric?

Edit (based on the comments below). I don't expect this to be true in general. I would be happy with something of the form: "The answer is known to be positive for all the members of $\mathcal C_1$, and negative for all the members of $\mathcal C_2$", where $\mathcal C_1$ and $\mathcal C_2$ are "non-trivial" classes of ("sufficiently small") topological monoids.

Thanks in advance for any possible pointer.

deleted 66 characters in body; edited tags
Source Link
Salvo Tringali
  • 10.5k
  • 2
  • 29
  • 64

Let me start by recalling some basic definitions (just for the sake of avoiding misunderstandings due to the vocabulary of the post).

Basically following some ideas of W. Lawvere (but not his terminology), we let a semimetric on a set $X$ be a function $d: X \times X \to [0,\infty]$ such that $d(x,x) = 0$ and $d(x,z) \le d(x,y) + d(y,z)$ for all $x,y,z \in X$. Exactly as with "classical" metrics, $d$ induces a topology on $X$, which we call the canonical topology of $d$, having as a base the sets $\{y \in X: d(x,y) < r\}$ as $x$ ranges over $X$ and $r$ over $\mathbf R^+$.

Next, we take a topological monoid to be, as usual, a pair $(\mathbb M, \tau)$ consisting of a (multiplicatively written) monoid $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ and a topology $\tau$ on $M$ such that $\cdot$ is continuous [...] in the expected sense.

Finally, if $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ is a monoid and $d$ is a semimetric on $M$, we say that $d$ is: right subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if $d(xz,yz) \le d(x,y)$ for all $x,y,z \in M$; left subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is right subinvariant in the dual of $\mathbb M$; and subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is both right and left subinvariant.

With all of this in mind, what is known about the following question?

Let $(\mathcal M, \tau)$ is$(\mathbb M, \tau)$ be a topological monoid, with $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$. Does there always exist a left (respectively, right) subinvariant semimetric $d$ on $M$ such that $\mathcal O$$\tau$ is the canonical topology of $d$? And what about a subinvariant semimetric?

Thanks in advance for any possible pointer.

P.S.: I'm not so sure about the tags to use for this question.

Let me start by recalling some basic definitions (just for the sake of avoiding misunderstandings due to the vocabulary of the post).

Basically following some ideas of W. Lawvere (but not his terminology), we let a semimetric on a set $X$ be a function $d: X \times X \to [0,\infty]$ such that $d(x,x) = 0$ and $d(x,z) \le d(x,y) + d(y,z)$ for all $x,y,z \in X$. Exactly as with "classical" metrics, $d$ induces a topology on $X$, which we call the canonical topology of $d$, having as a base the sets $\{y \in X: d(x,y) < r\}$ as $x$ ranges over $X$ and $r$ over $\mathbf R^+$.

Next, we take a topological monoid to be, as usual, a pair $(\mathbb M, \tau)$ consisting of a (multiplicatively written) monoid $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ and a topology $\tau$ on $M$ such that $\cdot$ is continuous [...] in the expected sense.

Finally, if $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ is a monoid and $d$ is a semimetric on $M$, we say that $d$ is: right subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if $d(xz,yz) \le d(x,y)$ for all $x,y,z \in M$; left subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is right subinvariant in the dual of $\mathbb M$; and subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is both right and left subinvariant.

With all of this in mind, what is known about the following question?

Let $(\mathcal M, \tau)$ is a topological monoid, with $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$. Does there always exist a left (respectively, right) subinvariant semimetric $d$ on $M$ such that $\mathcal O$ is the canonical topology of $d$? And what about a subinvariant semimetric?

Thanks in advance for any possible pointer.

P.S.: I'm not so sure about the tags to use for this question.

Let me start by recalling some basic definitions (just for the sake of avoiding misunderstandings due to the vocabulary of the post).

Basically following some ideas of W. Lawvere (but not his terminology), we let a semimetric on a set $X$ be a function $d: X \times X \to [0,\infty]$ such that $d(x,x) = 0$ and $d(x,z) \le d(x,y) + d(y,z)$ for all $x,y,z \in X$. Exactly as with "classical" metrics, $d$ induces a topology on $X$, which we call the canonical topology of $d$, having as a base the sets $\{y \in X: d(x,y) < r\}$ as $x$ ranges over $X$ and $r$ over $\mathbf R^+$.

Next, we take a topological monoid to be, as usual, a pair $(\mathbb M, \tau)$ consisting of a (multiplicatively written) monoid $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ and a topology $\tau$ on $M$ such that $\cdot$ is continuous [...] in the expected sense.

Finally, if $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ is a monoid and $d$ is a semimetric on $M$, we say that $d$ is: right subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if $d(xz,yz) \le d(x,y)$ for all $x,y,z \in M$; left subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is right subinvariant in the dual of $\mathbb M$; and subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is both right and left subinvariant.

With all of this in mind, what is known about the following question?

Let $(\mathbb M, \tau)$ be a topological monoid, with $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$. Does there always exist a left (respectively, right) subinvariant semimetric $d$ on $M$ such that $\tau$ is the canonical topology of $d$? And what about a subinvariant semimetric?

Thanks in advance for any possible pointer.

Source Link
Salvo Tringali
  • 10.5k
  • 2
  • 29
  • 64

If $(\mathbb M, \tau)$ is a topological monoid, is $\tau$ always induced by a [left] subinvariant semimetric?

Let me start by recalling some basic definitions (just for the sake of avoiding misunderstandings due to the vocabulary of the post).

Basically following some ideas of W. Lawvere (but not his terminology), we let a semimetric on a set $X$ be a function $d: X \times X \to [0,\infty]$ such that $d(x,x) = 0$ and $d(x,z) \le d(x,y) + d(y,z)$ for all $x,y,z \in X$. Exactly as with "classical" metrics, $d$ induces a topology on $X$, which we call the canonical topology of $d$, having as a base the sets $\{y \in X: d(x,y) < r\}$ as $x$ ranges over $X$ and $r$ over $\mathbf R^+$.

Next, we take a topological monoid to be, as usual, a pair $(\mathbb M, \tau)$ consisting of a (multiplicatively written) monoid $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ and a topology $\tau$ on $M$ such that $\cdot$ is continuous [...] in the expected sense.

Finally, if $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$ is a monoid and $d$ is a semimetric on $M$, we say that $d$ is: right subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if $d(xz,yz) \le d(x,y)$ for all $x,y,z \in M$; left subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is right subinvariant in the dual of $\mathbb M$; and subinvariant (in $\mathbb M$) if it is both right and left subinvariant.

With all of this in mind, what is known about the following question?

Let $(\mathcal M, \tau)$ is a topological monoid, with $\mathbb M = (M, \cdot)$. Does there always exist a left (respectively, right) subinvariant semimetric $d$ on $M$ such that $\mathcal O$ is the canonical topology of $d$? And what about a subinvariant semimetric?

Thanks in advance for any possible pointer.

P.S.: I'm not so sure about the tags to use for this question.