Skip to main content
Copied image to imgur.com, as it was not being displayed because of the new https rule. Added link to original image source.
Source Link

The Bean Machine, also known as a quincunx or the Galton box, is a well known triangular board that contains several rows ($n$) of staggered, but equally spaced pegs. Balls are dropped from the top one by one to avoid interference. They bounce off the pegs and stack up at the bottom of the triangle in bins. The resulting stacks of balls approach the characteristic Bell curve shape for large $n$.

Consider the following altered Bean Machine that now has all the 'prime numbered pegs' (counting top to bottom, left to right) removed:

http://s17.postimage.org/qqctbpftr/Galton_prime_box.jpg

(source)

Based on what is known about the primes, is there anything that could be predicted about the resulting distribution of balls for large $n$? Is it expected to be skewed to the left or the right? Or does it nicely balance out like the normal distribution?

Thanks.

The Bean Machine, also known as a quincunx or the Galton box, is a well known triangular board that contains several rows ($n$) of staggered, but equally spaced pegs. Balls are dropped from the top one by one to avoid interference. They bounce off the pegs and stack up at the bottom of the triangle in bins. The resulting stacks of balls approach the characteristic Bell curve shape for large $n$.

Consider the following altered Bean Machine that now has all the 'prime numbered pegs' (counting top to bottom, left to right) removed:

http://s17.postimage.org/qqctbpftr/Galton_prime_box.jpg

Based on what is known about the primes, is there anything that could be predicted about the resulting distribution of balls for large $n$? Is it expected to be skewed to the left or the right? Or does it nicely balance out like the normal distribution?

Thanks.

The Bean Machine, also known as a quincunx or the Galton box, is a well known triangular board that contains several rows ($n$) of staggered, but equally spaced pegs. Balls are dropped from the top one by one to avoid interference. They bounce off the pegs and stack up at the bottom of the triangle in bins. The resulting stacks of balls approach the characteristic Bell curve shape for large $n$.

Consider the following altered Bean Machine that now has all the 'prime numbered pegs' (counting top to bottom, left to right) removed:

(source)

Based on what is known about the primes, is there anything that could be predicted about the resulting distribution of balls for large $n$? Is it expected to be skewed to the left or the right? Or does it nicely balance out like the normal distribution?

Thanks.

Source Link
Agno
  • 4.2k
  • 21
  • 28

The distribution of balls in a Bean Machine that omits all the "prime pegs"?

The Bean Machine, also known as a quincunx or the Galton box, is a well known triangular board that contains several rows ($n$) of staggered, but equally spaced pegs. Balls are dropped from the top one by one to avoid interference. They bounce off the pegs and stack up at the bottom of the triangle in bins. The resulting stacks of balls approach the characteristic Bell curve shape for large $n$.

Consider the following altered Bean Machine that now has all the 'prime numbered pegs' (counting top to bottom, left to right) removed:

http://s17.postimage.org/qqctbpftr/Galton_prime_box.jpg

Based on what is known about the primes, is there anything that could be predicted about the resulting distribution of balls for large $n$? Is it expected to be skewed to the left or the right? Or does it nicely balance out like the normal distribution?

Thanks.