Skip to main content
Steven Stadnicki's user avatar
Steven Stadnicki's user avatar
Steven Stadnicki's user avatar
Steven Stadnicki
  • Member for 14 years, 6 months
  • Last seen this week
  • Seattle, WA
comment
Keller's cubing conjecture but with arbitrary cubes of side $1$
Ahhh! Somehow I missed that and thought you were talking about arbitrary sized cubes as well as orientations; mea culpa. Do you have a pointer to the coverings of R^3 that you mention? I'm trying to mentally grasp the mechanism there.
comment
Keller's cubing conjecture but with arbitrary cubes of side $1$
What would 'sharing a face' mean in the context of distinctly sized cubes? The faces being identical, or one being a subset of the other?
comment
What is the best lower bound for 3-sunflowers?
Isn't this exactly the same as the construction Eric Naslund gives in his answer?
comment
Tiling planar integer lattice by finite point sets
Surely $S=\{\langle 0,0\rangle, \langle 1,0\rangle, \langle 3,0\rangle\}$ can't tile $\mathbb{Z}\times\mathbb{Z}$ by translation? If it could then $\{0, 1, 3\}$ would translate $\mathbb{Z}$ by translation and this is clearly impossible.
comment
Frog game on tree graphs is in NP but not in P (NP-complete)?
You might want 'NP complete' — there are after all no problems known to be in NP and not in P...
comment
How to describe all integer solutions to $x^2+y^2=3z^2+1$?
You might want to see if you can chase down a copy of The Sensual Quadratic Form from John Conway; it talks about reductions of quadratic forms and gives various tree/hyperbolic structures that I suspect are germane to the transformation you give. There's also en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tree_of_primitive_Pythagorean_triples which may have some relevance, of course.
comment
Recurrence for permutation of A007306 (denominators of Farey tree fractions)
The question title and the body of the question refer to entirely different sequences.
comment
A simple stochastic game
Because it took me a moment to convince myself: the finiteness argument is that there's a $\epsilon$ such that for any position $P$ of the runner, a positive fraction of movement vectors $x$ have both $P+x$ and $P-x$ at least $\epsilon$ further from the origin than $P$, and therefore for any distance $d$ a positive probability of getting a sequence of moves (of length $\lceil d/\epsilon\rceil$) that force the runner to distance $d$ from the center.
comment
Will this Turing machine find a proof of its halting?
I was just about to mention Löb's theorem in a comment!
comment
$q$-binomial sum, slightly
(Speaking of which, I think your product in the q-Binomial theorem is slightly off? As written, the first term on the RHS is 2 which is clearly not the constant coefficient of the LHS.)
comment
$q$-binomial sum, slightly
Doing the same for $n=4$ gives $(q+1)(q^2+1)(q^3+1)(q^4+1)(q^5-q+1)$ which is starting to look very suspicious. Letting $\mathrm{Bin}[n]_q$ be the q-binomial product, this looks to possibly be $\mathrm{Bin}[n+1]_q-q\mathrm{Bin}[n]_q$? (ETA: modulo a potential off-by-one error, of course)
comment
$q$-binomial sum, slightly
For what it's worth, assuming I haven't typoed then plugging the $n=5$ into Wolfram Alpha, expanding out and then factoring gives the result $(q + 1)^3 (q^2 + 1) (q^2 - q + 1) (q^4 + 1) (q^4 - q^3 + q^2 - q + 1) (q^6 - q + 1)$ which certainly has a number of nice factors at least ($[3]_{-q}$ and $[5]_{-q}$ stand out); recombining these I see $(q+1)(q^2+1)(q^3+1)(q^4+1)(q^5+1)(q^6-q+1)$ which is very crisp looking. Where'd you come across this?
comment
Algorithm for finding the volume of a convex polytope
You're correct that the generalization is relatively straightforward, but there are two substantial complications that arise: (1) if given the convex polytope as an intersection of half-spaces rather than being explicitly given the cellular decomposition, then computing the vertex and adjacency information is known to be Hard in its own right; (2) the calculations to compute the individual simplex volumes require essentially finding the (n-1)-volume of each face and when you recurser down the simple methods for doing this take O(d!) time to handle a d-dimensional polytope.
comment
Maximal distance of set to integers
They're definitely not equivalent — it just seems to me that the question with individual values rather than differences is a little more 'natural' and I was curious how you came to this one.
comment
Maximal distance of set to integers
Are there specific reasons to look at a difference set rather than e.g. $\sup\min\min|\lambda x_i-n|$?
comment
Checking presence of a specific term in product polynomial
I'm about 75% sure you can encode SAT in this and that this is therefore NP-hard.
comment
Primes and chirality: a definition and question in the context of tessellations for squares
I'm hard-pressed to see the relation between primality and chirality — it's true that the representation of a number as a product exhibits a specific achiral polyomino of that number, but it's easy to show that any $N$ whether prime or not has a chiral polyomino, and likewise easy to show that any $N\gt 3$ whether prime or not has a non-trivial achiral polyomino.
comment
determine degree of boolean polynomial given as black box
Doesn't a classical algorithm per force have to look at all the points of the domain, since every boolean function on $n$ variables is representable as a degree-$n$ polynomial? That means that you can't beat $2^n$ queries and I suspect that the time to determine degree from that set is at worst polynomially bounded in the number of points, so you're looking at 'just' exponentially many operations to go with your exponentially many queries.
comment
How to count the total zeros of a complex polynomial outside a closed curve?
@Guoqing I'm not sure I see how you can integrate $f()$ without knowing $n$ — after all, it's in the very definition of $f$!
comment
Has this number-theoretic constant been studied?
Don't you mean to set $\zeta(1)^{-1}=-12$? (Joke, joke! Put down the pitchforks...)
1
7 8
9
10 11
35