Skip to main content
CoffeDeveloper's user avatar
CoffeDeveloper's user avatar
CoffeDeveloper's user avatar
CoffeDeveloper
  • Member for 10 years, 10 months
  • Last seen more than a month ago
  • GB Road, Manoramanagar, Srinagar Colony, Thane West, Thane, Maharashtra, India
comment
Can we decide whenever a function is the derivate of another function in this Language?
My feeling is that someone just "says" is because "other says". How to be sure someone is right, if he cannot show why is right (not speaking of you I'm in general sayings)?. Also your claim "to any set of E" is quite generic and assumes that you defined E as Richardson, if E in example is just a polynomial your claim do not hold anymore. People pretends me to be precise in the question, but then do generic answers without contextualization while it is obvious to everyone what I did not understand, no one cared to explain ^^.
comment
Can we decide whenever a function is the derivate of another function in this Language?
That's because you know what the theorem is about, if you read it on Wikipedia it is not clear at all. Everyone is good to criticize and downvote when someone do not understand because someone else wrote that in a bad way. Math should not be elitarie in any way. Everyone here just sad "that's obvious", but math is not at all obviouse, you have to show it is obvious. Math is made by many steps, if it is not clear enough you should explain what is missing step. Not insisting in "it is that way." show that way ^^.
awarded
comment
Can we decide whenever a function is the derivate of another function in this Language?
Now I understand but I think it is more clear in the following way: "Since expressions mentioned in Richardson theorem are a subset of mine expressions, then mine expressions have a subset for which some expressions are not decidable on the condition." No one still exclude then that expressions using at least one time the "square root" function may be trivially decidable then. About the usage of $|x|$ I still have some doubts but Thanks for the spotlight. ^^
Loading…
revised
Loading…
revised
Loading…
awarded
revised
Loading…
revised
Can we decide whenever a function is the derivate of another function in this Language?
removed pow function which is not trivial to derivate nor is taught in high-school
Loading…
awarded
revised
Loading…
revised
Can we decide whenever a function is the derivate of another function in this Language?
added subset of derivation rules for my language and fixed a few points in the bullet list
Loading…
comment
Can we decide whenever a function is the derivate of another function in this Language?
I do not understan why, Richardson use "abs" and don't have "sqrt and pow" functions.. Maybe you can link the theorem in an answer @EmilJeřábek ? (at least according to wikipedia page) I'm not going to trust a theorem without explaination if I'm not working under the assumptions of the theorem
Loading…
revised
Loading…
revised
Loading…
comment
Can we decide whenever a function is the derivate of another function in this Language?
I edited to made it very formal so that everyone is happy and can understand now ^^
revised
Can we decide whenever a function is the derivate of another function in this Language?
Made it more formal, and removed a statement that would made the set decidable by definition
Loading…