Skip to main content
Quarto Bendir's user avatar
Quarto Bendir's user avatar
Quarto Bendir's user avatar
Quarto Bendir
  • Member for 4 years, 8 months
  • Last seen this week
comment
Is there any connection between the Deturck trick and the Uhlenbeck trick?
It may be worth noting that the DeTurck trick is nonlinear, amounting to a coupling with the harmonic map heat flow, and the Uhlenbeck trick is from a linear ODE, resulting in a one-parameter family of self-maps of the set of bases of a tangent space. So arguably one shouldn't expect any relation.
comment
About the paper "Elements of Morse theory on Alexandrov spaces"
English translation is at St. Petersburg Math. J. 5 (1994), no. 1, 205–213, I can't find it on the web though
Loading…
comment
Two possible meanings of "totally real" submanifold
It is of course true that the second definition doesn't need a metric. But it is unusual and not great for the addition of a structure to modify or restrict the meaning of of a definition. Is there any typical language for both definitions which is compatible with one another?
Loading…
comment
revised
Loading…
comment
Functions which are periodic along every geodesic
thanks for the article, I've added a comment about it to the question
revised
Loading…
comment
Functions which are periodic along every geodesic
I'm not sure. Supposing it does, I think my condition should be significantly more restrictive, since I assume the lengths of geodesics in Besse's manifolds aren't usually all multiples of the same number
Loading…
comment
Perturbation in the equation $u_t=\epsilon Pu$, where $P$ is an elliptic partial differential operator
Depending on the particular applications you're interested in you might want to look at Eberhard Hopf "The partial differential equation $u_t+uu_x=\mu u_{xx}$" Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 3 (1950), no. 3, 201-230, or S.N. Kruzkov "First order quasilinear equations in several independent variables," which are concerned with these kinds of questions
comment
Classification of conformal diffeomorphisms of Minkowski space, part 2
The Liouville theorem 5.4 in Slovak's article gives the conformal group by giving a list of generators. I believe makt would like a parametrization of the group, e.g. the isometry group is more precisely described as mappings "Ax+b" rather than "the group generated by rotations and translations"
Loading…
comment
Proving an identity used in general relativity
That's fair. When I called it the Reilly formula I was thinking of the case of a closed manifold
revised
Proving an identity used in general relativity
added 379 characters in body
Loading…
answered
Loading…
comment
Replication crisis in mathematics
I agree that the standard textbook material in math must be among the most reliable in the sciences. And I think that what you say applies to certain results and certain methods in modern practice, but that a majority of research does not directly become part of the ecosystem in that way. In part it's like Voevoedksy said, "A technical argument by a trusted author, which is hard to check and looks similar to arguments known to be correct, is hardly ever checked in detail." I think such an instance is not naturally checked against by #2 and 3, although of course in certain cases it is.
comment
Replication crisis in mathematics
I agree, but I don't see how that's helpful for the problem of a present-day mathematician understanding present-day mathematics research, which is what I understand the replication crisis to be about.
comment
Replication crisis in mathematics
It seems that some of your points #1-4 do indicate that most major theorems are correct, but it seems that none of them address the problem of proofs failing to be understandable or replicable to readers
1
5
6
7 8 9