revised
Need proof on a model being elementarily equivalent but non-isomorphic
deleted 3 characters in body
Loading…
comment
Need proof on a model being elementarily equivalent but non-isomorphic
@EugeneZhang Yes, I believe so. (I have a macro on my keyboard that transform \phi into the Unicode symbol φ [which has the LaTeX commend of \varphi], and the macro probably didn't work for that one instance)
revised
Can there exist a definable "ultrafilter" on the ordinals?
Fix tags to be more precise
Loading…
awarded
awarded
awarded
comment
Building the real from Dedekind finite sets
Thanks for the answer! I still didn't have time to go through the answer in depth, but about the last paragraph, $A^{<\omega}$ is not Dedekind finite (as witness by e.g. constant $a$ sequence of length $n$ for fixed $a$). I think we want to look only at $A^{1-1}×A$, the surjectivity argument should still follow
awarded
comment
Building the real from Dedekind finite sets
@GuozhenShen I did thought about trying to force such surjection (e.g. starting with Cohen model, and trying to add a surjection to the reals from the canonical Dedekind set) but I couldn't quite see how it will turn out
comment
Building the real from Dedekind finite sets
@GuozhenShen thanks, I'll check the paper out.
revised
Building the real from Dedekind finite sets
deleted 85 characters in body
Loading…
revised
Building the real from Dedekind finite sets
added 152 characters in body
Loading…
Loading…
comment
Proof of global Peano existence theorem in ZF?
@MikhailKatz everything in Peano's theorem is countably coded, so you don't lose anything when translating it to ZF. Sometimes you do have cases where WKL_0 (or other weak systems) proves statement A but not prove statement B, but ZF- (or other strong system) prove that A is equivalent to B, fortunately it is not the case here, Simpson proved Peano's theorem in it's original form
comment
Proof of global Peano existence theorem in ZF?
@MikhailKatz Lebesgue measurable sets are not countably coded
comment
Proof of global Peano existence theorem in ZF?
@MikhailKatz by "pure existential statement" James means Peano's existence theorem without the additional "global" condition (that there is a maximal interval). Not sure what you mean by "equivalent to the usual ZF version", ZF proves everything that ${\sf {WKL}}_0$ can prove when talking about sets of naturals (i.e. reals)
comment
Proof of global Peano existence theorem in ZF?
Stephen G. Simpson has shown that over RCA_0, Peano's existence theorem is equivalent to WKL. I would imagine that adding the maximality condition is possible without too much effort
awarded