Let $A \to B$ be a map of commutative rings, and $d : B \to I/I^2$ be defined by $df = f\otimes 1 - 1\otimes f$, where $I$ is the kernel of $B \otimes_A B \to B$, as in [Hartshorne II.8].

If $df=0$, I would like to infer that $f \in A$, i.e. "if the derivative is zero, the function is constant".

This is certainly $\bf false$, e.g. $A = {\mathbb F}_p$, $B = A[x]$, and $f=x^p$. There $B\otimes_A B\to B$ is $A[x_1,x_2] \mapsto A[x]$, with $I = \langle x_1 -x_2\rangle \ni x_1^p - x_2^p = f\otimes 1 - 1\otimes f$. (That is, not only is $f\otimes 1 - 1\otimes f$ in $I^2$, it's in $I^p$.)

What is the right condition, then, on $A\to B\ $? My primary interest is in $A = {\mathbb Z}[1/d]$.

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ After teaching 3 hrs, my brain is shot. Here some thoughts which may only be quasicoherent. If $A$ is a field of char $p>0$, there is not much hope. If $A$ is a field of char $0$, and $B$ has a a domain of finite type, then you should be OK by the algebraic de Rham theorem which implies $H^0_{DR}(B)=A$. Perhaps in your situation, you can pass to the fraction field? $\endgroup$ Sep 13 '11 at 18:59
  • $\begingroup$ @Donu: I like (and use) your idea of passing to Frac($A$). But over a field you just have to be carefull with finite extensions $B/A$ for which $H^0_{DR}(B)=B$. $\endgroup$
    – Qing Liu
    Sep 14 '11 at 0:20
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Shouldn't that be: "if the derivative is zero, the function is locally constant"? $\endgroup$
    – user2035
    Sep 14 '11 at 7:45
  • $\begingroup$ Qing Liu, thanks. Nice answer, by the way. A-fortiori, certainly, although I don't think he meant it literally. $\endgroup$ Sep 14 '11 at 8:29
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ a-fortiori, I do point out that it's false! Basically your worry is that the fiber of Spec B -> Spec A may not be connected. In Qing Liu's very nice sufficient condition, the generic fiber is geometrically integral, which is how he addresses your issue. $\endgroup$ Sep 14 '11 at 11:11

I will rather regard $I/I^2$ as $\Omega_{B/A}$, the module of differential forms.

First some necessary conditions. If $D$ is a sub-$A$-algebra of $B$ such that $\Omega_{D/A}=0$ (e.g. $D$ is a localization of $A$ or étale over $A$), the canonical map $\Omega_{D/A}\otimes_D B\to \Omega_{B/A}$ shows that $df=0$ for all $f\in D$. So if $A$ is a field (of characteristic $0$), you want it to be algebraically closed in $B$. If $A$ is not a field, to avoid $B$ to contain a localization of $A$, you almost want to suppose $\mathrm{Spec} B\to \mathrm{Spec}A$ be surjective.

These being said, now a sufficient condition.

Suppose $A$ is noetherian, integrally closed of characteristic $0$, $B$ is an integral domain, $\mathrm{Spec} B\to \mathrm{Spec}A$ is surjective, and its generic fiber is smooth of finite type and geometrically integral. Then the kernel of $B\to \Omega_{B/A}$ is equal to $A$.


(1) Let $C$ be the kernel of $d : B\to \Omega_{B/A}$. This is a sub-$A$-algebra of $B$. The canonical exact sequence $$ \Omega_{C/A}\otimes_C B\to \Omega_{B/A}\to \Omega_{B/C}\to 0$$ implies that $\Omega_{B/A}\to \Omega_{B/C}$ is an isomorphism because the first map is identically zero ($dc\otimes b\mapsto bdc=0$ if $c\in C$).

(2) Let $K=\mathrm{Frac}(A)$, $L=\mathrm{Frac}(B)$. Let us first show that $E:=\mathrm{ker}(L\to\Omega_{L/K})$ equals to $K$. Note that $E$ is a field. Applying (1) to the situation $A=K$ and $B=L$, we see that $\Omega_{L/K}\to \Omega_{L/E}$ is an isomorphism. This map is $L$-linear, and $\dim_L\Omega_{L/K}$ is the transcendental degree of $L$ over $K$ (here we use the characteristic zero hypothesis). Similarly for $L/E$. Hence $E$ is algebraic over $K$. But $B_K$ is geometrically integral over $K$, this forces $E=K$ (otherwise $L\otimes_K E$ is not integral).

(3) Let us show $C_K:=C\otimes_A K$ equals to $K$. Tensoring the exact sequence of $A$-modules $$ 0\to C\to B\to \Omega_{B/A}$$ by $K$, we get the exact sequence $$ 0\to C_K \to B_K \to \Omega_{B_K/K}. $$ First suppose $B_K$ is smooth over $K$. As $\Omega_{L/K}$ is a localization of $\Omega_{B_K/K}$ and the latter is a free (hence torsion free) $B_K$-module, the map $\Omega_{B_K/K}\to \Omega_{L/K}$ is injective. By (2) we then get $C_K=K$. In the general case, some dense open subset $U$ of $\mathrm{Spec}(B_K)$ is smooth. If $f\in B_K$ satisfies $df=0$ in $\Omega_{B_K/K}$, then $d(f_{|U})=0$ in $\Omega_{U/K}$. So $f{|_U}\in K$. As $B_K\to O(U)$ is injective, $f\in K$.

(4) Let us show $C=A$. We have $C\subseteq B\cap K$ (in fact the equality holds). So we have to show $B\cap K=A$. Let $g\in B\cap K$ viewed as a rational function on $\mathrm{Spec}(A)$. Then $A\subseteq A[g]\subseteq B$. For any prime ideal $Q$ of $B$, $g$ is regular at the point $Q\cap A$. So the image of $\pi : \mathrm{Spec}(B)\to \mathrm{Spec}(A)$ is contained in the complementary of the pole divisor of $g$. So the latter is empty by the surjectivity hypothesis on $\pi$. Therefore $g$ is a regular function (here we use the normality of $A$) and $C=A$.

Add Suppose $A, B$ are integral domains of characteristic $0$, $B_K$ is finitely generated over $K=\mathrm{Frac}(A)$, and $\Omega_{B_K/K}$ is torsion free over $B_K$. Then we proved above that the kernel of $d: B\to\Omega_{B/A}$ is contained in $B\cap K^{alg}$.

Add 2 One can remove free or torsion-free condition on $\Omega_{B_K/K}$. The proof is a little modified in the step 3. We just notice that any integral variety in characteristic $0$ has a dense open subset which is smooth !

  • $\begingroup$ Better and better! $\endgroup$ Sep 15 '11 at 0:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.