Reading the book of Goess-Jardine or of Gabriel-Zisman on the simplicial homotopy there are coker presentation of the boundary $\partial\Delta^n $ of the elementary simplex $\Delta^n $ or the horn $\Lambda^n_k $ (see GOerss-Jardine "Simplicial Homotopy Theory" pag.9) .

Now the image of this presentation coker diagram by the topological realization functor $T: S \to Top$ (where $S$ category of functors from $\Delta^{ op }$ to $Set$, and $Top$ category of topological spaces) is of course still a coker diagram (the functor $T$ preserves colimits being a left adjoint) , a separate verification that this latter is a coequalizers (of topological spaces) is evident (or at most geometrically intuitive). Of course is a no hard problem give a demonstration that also the original presentation (by simplicial spaces) is a coequalizer.

Anyway this little question has suggested me the follow question:

Let $\iota: \coprod \Delta \subset S$ the subcategory by object the finite coproducts of representales , and by morphisms constructed from morphisms between representable and coprojections. Considering the restriction functor $T\circ \iota: \coprod \Delta \to Top $, the question is:

This functors reflex cokernels?


I claim that geometric realization reflects colimits of all sorts. That is, given a functor $F: C\to sSet$ and a cocone $\{F(C_i)\to X\}$ in $sSet$ such that $\newcommand{\colim}{\operatorname{colim}}T(\colim_C F)\to T(X)$ is a bijection, then $\colim_C F\to X$ is an isomorphism of simplicial sets.

Recall that geometric realization $T:S\to Top$ preserves all colimits. Thus, it is enough to show that if $f:X\to Y$ is a map of simplicial sets such that $T(f)$ is a bijection, then $f$ is an isomorphism.

To show this, I want to use the notion of a nongenerate simplex of a simplicial set $X$, and the fact that every simplex $x\in X_n$ is the degeneracy of a unique non-degenerate simplex $t\in X_k$, and is so in a unique way (i.e., there is a unique surjective map $\sigma:[n]\to [k]$ in $\Delta$ such that $(X\sigma)(t)=x$; this fact is sometimes called the "Eilenberg-Zilber lemma".)

Given this, it is not hard to show the following.

  1. Let $f:X\to Y$ be a map of simplical sets such that (i) if $s\in X_n$ is non-degenerate, then $f(s)\in Y_n$ is non-degenerate, and (ii) if $s,s'\in X_n$ are non-degenerate and $f(s)=f(s')$, then $s=s'$. It follows that $f$ is injective.
  2. If $f:X\to Y$ is a map of simplicial sets such that for each non-degenerate $t\in Y_k$, there exists a non-degenerate $s$ in some $X_n$ such that $f(s)$ is a degeneracy of $t$ (or $f(s)=t$, when $n=k$), then $f$ is surjective.

Now consider the geometric realization $TX$ of a simplicial set $X$. As a set, this has the form of a disjoint union $$ TX \approx \bigcup_n \bigcup_\sigma (\Delta^n-\partial\Delta^n),$$ where the $\sigma$ range over non-degenerate $n$-simplices. It is not hard to see how this behaves as a functor: a map $f:X\to Y$ induces a map $Tf:TX\to TY$ which sends the boundaryless simplex of corresponding to a non-degenerate $\sigma\in X_n$ to the bondaryless simplex corresponding to the non-degenerate $\tau\in Y_k$, where $\tau$ the non-degenerate simplex of which $f(\sigma)$ is degenerate (or, if $f(\sigma)$ is non-degnererate, then $f(\sigma)=\tau$.) The resulting map of boundaryless simplices $(\Delta^n-\partial \Delta^n)\to (\Delta^k-\partial \Delta^k)$ is described by a surjective map $[n]\to [k]$ in $\Delta$, and can be bijective only if $n=k$.

Given this, it's easy to check that if $Tf$ is a bijection, then the conditions of (1) and (2) must be satisfied, so $f$ must be bijective too.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.