6
$\begingroup$

Define the unit-stick number $\sigma_1(K)$ of a knot $K$ to be the fewest unit-length sticks that can realize $K$.
Clearly $\sigma_1(K)$ is at least the stick number $\sigma(K)$. It is known that the trefoil knot $K_{3_1}$ has stick number $6$; see the image below. I believe, although I don't have a formal proof, that $\sigma_1(K_{3_1})=6$: the trefoil also has unit-stick number $6$.

      
(Wikipedia image by Wiebew. The sticks are not all the same length.)

Q. Is $\sigma_1(K) = \sigma(K)$ for every knot $K$? If not, what is a knot for which it can be proved that the unit-stick number is strictly greater than the stick number, $\sigma_1(K) > \sigma(K)$?


Related: Which knots' stick numbers are twice their crossing numbers?.


Update. User @aorq's comment shows that my "unit-stick number" has been studied under the name "equilateral stick number":

Rawdon, Eric J., and Robert G. Scharein. "Upper bounds for equilateral stick numbers." Contemporary Mathematics 304 (2002): 55-76.

These authors proved that indeed the trefoil has equilateral stick number $6$. They identify the $8_{19}$ knot as possibly one whose equilateral stick number is greater than its stick number. So, about $20$ years ago, it appears that the question I posed was an open problem.

      TrefoilEqStick

$\endgroup$
2
  • 5
    $\begingroup$ colab.sfu.ca/KnotPlot/eqsticks.pdf $\endgroup$
    – aorq
    Commented Jun 3, 2021 at 13:33
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Apparently "Kenneth C Millett. Physical knot theory: An introduction to the study of the influence of knotting on the spatial characteristics of polymers. In Louis H Kauffman, Sofia Lambropoulou, Slavik Jablan, and Jozef H Przytycki, editors, ´ Introductory Lectures on Knot Theory, volume 46 of Series on Knots and Everything, pages 346–378. World Scientific Publishing, Singapore, 2012" finds that $8_{19}$ specifically is not a counterexample. See arxiv.org/abs/1909.00917 $\endgroup$
    – aorq
    Commented Jun 3, 2021 at 14:37

0

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .