Let $f: X\rightarrow S$ be a quasi-compact, quasi-separated, flat morphism of schemes, with $S$ locally Noetherian. Also, fix an integer $i\geq 1$.

Question 1: Does $H^i(X_s,\mathcal{O}_{X_s})=0$, for all $s\in S$, imply that $R^if_\ast\mathcal{O}_X=0$?

The answer is yes, if $f$ is also assumed to be proper (flat base change+theorem of formal functions+easy direct proof for $S$ Artinian local). In general, I would expect that there are some simple counterexamples but, to my surprise, I didn't find anything in the literature - probably I simply looked in the wrong places! I should also add that I would be particularly interested in counterexamples in characteristic zero, i.e. where $f$ is a morphism of schemes over a field of characteristic zero.

Here is a variant of question 1:

Question 2: Assume in addition that $f$ has a section $e: S\rightarrow X$. What is the answer to question 1 then?

The "raison d'être" for asking question 2 in addition is that a colleague explained to me how, granting existence of a section, the assumptions above ensure that $H^0(X_s,\mathcal{O}_{X_s})=\kappa(s)$, for all $s\in S$, implies that $f_\ast\mathcal{O}_X=\mathcal{O}_S$. So, at least in this very special case, the fibres of $f$ "remember" what the global sections of $f$ are.


Here is one simple counterexample:

Example. Let $X = \mathbf A^2 \setminus 0$ and $S = \mathbf A^1$, where $f \colon X \to S$ is the first coordinate projection. The fibres are affine, so have no higher coherent cohomology.

But if $V \subseteq S$ is affine open containing $0$, then $f^{-1}(V)$ has an affine open cover by $U_1 = V \times \mathbf G_m$ and $U_2 = (V \setminus 0) \times \mathbf A^1$. Then the function $\tfrac{1}{xy}$ on $U_{12}$ is not a sum of functions on $U_1$ and $U_2$, so it gives a nonzero class in $(R^1f_* \mathcal O_X)_0$. $\square$

(Note that this map has many sections.)

  • $\begingroup$ Great, that's as simple as I was hoping for! Many thanks. $\endgroup$ Jun 17 '20 at 8:13

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.