Say I have a cluster algebra with principal coefficients and initial cluster $x_1,\ldots,x_n$. I don't want to invert the coefficient variables $y_1,\ldots,y_n$. The Laurent Phenomenon says that every cluster variable (and thus every element of the cluster algebra) is a Laurent polynomial in the $x_i$ with coefficients integer polynomials in the $y_i$.
The question is simple: If I hand you an expression for a Laurent polynomial in the $x_i$ with coefficients integer polynomials in the $y_i$, can you tell me if it is an element of the cluster algebra?
Answers might take the form of a criterion that could be checked by hand or an algorithm. I would also be interested in algorithms or partial criteria that can provide answers in some cases but not all cases.