I'm reading Katznelson's book "Harmonic Analysis" and there is an exercise that I can't solve :

Show that if the sequence $\left\{ N_j \right\} $ tends to infinity fast enough, then the Fourier series of the function $$ f(t)=\sum_{j>0}2^{-j }K_{N_j}$$ does not converge in $L^1(\mathbb{T})$.

$K_{N_j}$ denotes the Féjer Kernel.

In a first time I tried to compute the Fourier coefficients of $f$. If $N_l<n\leq N_{l+1}$ then $\hat{f}(n)=\sum _{j> l}2^{-j}(1-\frac{|n|}{N_j+1})=\hat{f}(-n)$. So I have tried to show that $(S_n(f))$ is not a Cauchy sequence with the $L^1$ norm but I failed to find a good enough lower bound of $\int _{\mathbb{T}}|\sum _{p}^{q}\hat{f}(n) cos(nt)| dt$


Let us give sufficient conditions on the growth rate of $N_l$ for the Fourier series to diverge.

We consider $p = N_l + 1$ and $q = \frac1M N_{l+1}$. For $p < |n| \leq q$ we have that $$ \hat{f}(n) = \sum_{j > l} 2^{-j}(1 - \frac{|n|}{N_j + 1}) \geq (1 - \frac{1}{M}) \sum_{j > l} 2^{-j} = (1 - \frac{1}M) \cdot 2^{-l}$$ we also have $$ \hat{f}(n) - (1 - \frac1M) \cdot 2^{-l} \leq \frac1M \cdot 2^{-l}.$$


$$ \left| \sum_{p}^q \hat{f}(n) \cos(nt)\right| \geq (1 - \frac1M)2^{-l} \left|\sum_{p}^{q} \cos(nt)\right| - \frac{q-p}{M} 2^{-l} = (1 - \frac1M)2^{-l} |D_q(t) - D_p(t)| - \frac{q-p}{M} 2^{-l}.$$

Now you can use the divergence of the Dirichlet kernel (this follows from the fact that the $L^1$ norm of the Dirichlet kernel grows like $\log n$).

  1. Given $N_l$, we choose $q$ such that $\| D_{q} - D_{N_{l}+1}\|_{L^1} \geq 2^{l}$.
  2. Next we choose $M$ such that $M > 2 (q - N_{l} - 1)$.
  3. We choose $N_{l+1} > M q$.
  4. repeat with $l \mapsto l+1$.

Then we have

$$ \|S_q(f) - S_p(f)\|_{L^1} \geq \frac12 ( 1 - 2^{-l}) $$

for the $p,q$ associated to each $l$, showing that the Fourier series cannot converge in $L^1$.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.