4
$\begingroup$

I have the following functional $$F(y)=\left[\int \frac{1}{y(x)+A}\cos(x)dx\right]^2$$ How do I find the functional derivative $dF$?

(I never encountered the square of an integral before when I did functional derivatives)

$\endgroup$
1
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ There is a chain rule for functional derivatives. $\endgroup$ Commented Aug 7, 2012 at 14:27

1 Answer 1

4
$\begingroup$

Replace $y$ by $y+t\delta y$ and then compute

$$\lim_{t\to 0} \Bigl(\; F(y+t\delta y)-F(y)\;\Bigr). $$

Here are the details. Observe first that

$$\frac{1}{y+ A+ t\delta y}-\frac{1}{y+A} = -\frac{1}{(y+A)^2} t\delta y+ O(t^2),$$

so that

$$F(y+t\delta y)= \left(\int\;\Bigl(\; \frac{1}{y+A} -\frac{1}{(y+A)^2} t\delta y+O(t^2)\;\Bigr) \cos(x) dx\right)^2 $$

$$= F(y) -2t\left(\int\frac{\cos (x)}{y+A}\right)\left(\int\frac{(\delta y)\cos(x)}{\bigl(y+A)^2} dx\right) +O(t^2). $$

From here you can read that

$$\frac{\delta F}{\delta y} =-2 \left(\int\frac{\cos (x)}{y+A}dx\right)\frac{\cos(x)}{\bigl(\;y(x)+A \;\bigr)^2} $$

Update 1. Here are some rules that will help you solve the problem you mentioned in your comment.

Suppose that $I$ is an interval. If

$$F(y) =\int_I f(y(x)) w(x) dx.$$

Then

$$\frac{\delta F}{\delta y}= f'(y(x)) w(x). \tag{1} $$

If

$$ F(y)=\left| \int_I f(y) w(x) dx\right|^2, $$

$w$ complex valued, then $\DeclareMathOperator{\re}{\boldsymbol{Re}}$

$$\frac{\delta F}{\delta y}= 2\re\left(\; f'(y(x)) \overline{w(x)} \int_I f(y) w(x) dx \;\right) \tag{2} $$

Let me set

$$ F_1(y)=\int_I \frac{A}{y(x)+ A} dx,\;\;I=(-\kappa \pi,\kappa\pi), $$

$$ F_2(y) =\left|\int_I \frac{A}{y(x)+ A} e^{- i x} dx\right|^2, $$

$$ E(y) = F_1-\frac{F_2}{F_1} $$

Then

$$ \frac{\delta E}{\delta y} =\frac{\delta F_1}{\delta y} -\frac{ \frac{\delta F_2}{\delta y} F_1- F_2\frac{\delta F_1}{\delta y} }{ F_1(y)^2 }. $$

Now compute the various derivatives using (1) and (2).

Your problem reduces via Lagrange multipliers to the system

$$\frac{\delta E}{\delta y} =\lambda,\;\;\int_I y dx=1. $$

Update 2. Introduce a new variable

$$ y=\frac{A}{G+A},\;\;G= \frac{A}{y}-A. $$

The constraint

$$ \int G = const $$

becomes

$$C(y)= \int\frac{1}{y} =const $$

and the energy functional becomes

$$E(y)=\int y -\frac{\left|\int ye^{-i x}\right|^2}{\int y }. $$

The constrained Euler-Lagrange equations have the form

$$\frac{\delta E}{\delta y}=\lambda\frac{\delta C}{\delta y}=-\frac{\lambda}{y^2} \tag{3} $$

Which translates into an equality of the form

$$C_1(y) y^2+ C_2(y) \cos x +C_3(y) \sin x= C_4(y)-\lambda C_1(y)^2, $$

where $C_i(y)$ are constants that depend explicitly on $y$, e.g.,

$$C_1(y)=\left(\int y\right)^2. $$

Now at least you know that $y$ must be of a rather special form

$$ y =\sqrt{ A_1+A_2\cos x+ A_3\sin x}. $$ If you play with (3) some more I bet that you can extract more precise info.

$\endgroup$
3
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks. This was only a part of a bigger thing. Would you mind also taking a look at the following? $I(G(\omega)) = \int_{-\kappa\pi}^{\kappa\pi} \frac{A}{G(\omega)+A}d\omega-\frac{| \int_{-\kappa\pi}^{\kappa\pi} \frac{A}{G(\omega)+A}\exp(-i\omega)d\omega|^2}{ \int_{-\kappa\pi}^{\kappa\pi} \frac{A}{G(\omega)+A}d\omega}$, where $\kappa<1$, $A>0$, and $G(\omega)\geq 0$. Now I would like to minimize $I(G(\omega))$ under the constraint of unit area of $G(\omega)$, i.e., $\int_{-\kappa \pi}^{\kappa \pi} G(\omega)d\omega=1$. My hypothesis is that a flat $G(\omega)=1/2\kappa\pi$ is optimal. $\endgroup$ Commented Aug 7, 2012 at 18:56
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks, Do you foresee any possibilities to actually solve the system? I tried it out, but get stuck pretty fast.... $\endgroup$ Commented Aug 8, 2012 at 14:14
  • $\begingroup$ Try to use the ideas in Update 2. $\endgroup$ Commented Aug 8, 2012 at 17:26

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .