Skip to main content
formatting, added tag
Source Link
YCor
  • 63.9k
  • 5
  • 187
  • 286

Let $ G $ be a simple linear algebraic group. Let $ G_\mathbb{R} $ be the real points of $ G $. Let $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ be the integer points of $ G $. Is $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ a maximal closed subgroup? In other words, are the only closed subgroups $ H $ of $ G_\mathbb{R} $ such that $$ G_\mathbb{Z} \subset H \subset G_\mathbb{R} $$ just $ G_\mathbb{R} $ and $ G_{\mathbb{Z}} $?

The answer is yes for for $SO_3$$\operatorname{SO}_3$. $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{Z}) $ is the 24 element octohedral group (isomorphic to the symmetric group $ S_4 $) and this group is a maximal finite subgroup of rotations and indeed it turns out that adding any other rotation and taking the closure will generate all of $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{R})$.

The group of integer points is also maximal in $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb R) $. See the answer by YCor given to Is $SL_2(\mathbb Z)$$\operatorname{SL}_2(\mathbb Z)$ a maximal discrete subgroup in $SL_2(\mathbb R)$$\operatorname{SL}_2(\mathbb R)$?.

Although this only states that $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb{Z}) $ is maximal among discrete subgroups I'm guessing that it is in fact maximal among closed subgroups as well in this case.

Let $ G $ be a simple linear algebraic group. Let $ G_\mathbb{R} $ be the real points of $ G $. Let $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ be the integer points of $ G $. Is $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ a maximal closed subgroup? In other words, are the only closed subgroups $ H $ of $ G_\mathbb{R} $ such that $$ G_\mathbb{Z} \subset H \subset G_\mathbb{R} $$ just $ G_\mathbb{R} $ and $ G_{\mathbb{Z}} $?

The answer is yes for for $SO_3$. $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{Z}) $ is the 24 element octohedral group (isomorphic to the symmetric group $ S_4 $) and this group is a maximal finite subgroup of rotations and indeed it turns out that adding any other rotation and taking the closure will generate all of $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{R})$.

The group of integer points is also maximal in $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb R) $. See the answer by YCor given to Is $SL_2(\mathbb Z)$ a maximal discrete subgroup in $SL_2(\mathbb R)$?.

Although this only states that $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb{Z}) $ is maximal among discrete subgroups I'm guessing that it is in fact maximal among closed subgroups as well in this case.

Let $ G $ be a simple linear algebraic group. Let $ G_\mathbb{R} $ be the real points of $ G $. Let $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ be the integer points of $ G $. Is $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ a maximal closed subgroup? In other words, are the only closed subgroups $ H $ of $ G_\mathbb{R} $ such that $$ G_\mathbb{Z} \subset H \subset G_\mathbb{R} $$ just $ G_\mathbb{R} $ and $ G_{\mathbb{Z}} $?

The answer is yes for for $\operatorname{SO}_3$. $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{Z}) $ is the 24 element octohedral group (isomorphic to the symmetric group $ S_4 $) and this group is a maximal finite subgroup of rotations and indeed it turns out that adding any other rotation and taking the closure will generate all of $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{R})$.

The group of integer points is also maximal in $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb R) $. See the answer by YCor given to Is $\operatorname{SL}_2(\mathbb Z)$ a maximal discrete subgroup in $\operatorname{SL}_2(\mathbb R)$?.

Although this only states that $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb{Z}) $ is maximal among discrete subgroups I'm guessing that it is in fact maximal among closed subgroups as well in this case.

deleted 23 characters in body
Source Link

Is the group of integer points of a simple real linear algebraic group a maximal closed subgroup?

Let $ G $ be a simple linear algebraic group. Let $ G_\mathbb{R} $ be the real points of $ G $. Let $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ be the integer points of $ G $. Is $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ a maximal closed subgroup? In other words, are the only closed subgroups $ H $ of $ G_\mathbb{R} $ such that $$ G_\mathbb{Z} \subset H \subset G_\mathbb{R} $$ just $ G_\mathbb{R} $ and $ G_{\mathbb{Z}} $?

Integer points are in denseThe answer is yes for for $ \operatorname{SO}_3 $$SO_3$. $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{Z}) $ is the 24 element octohedral group (isomorphic to the symmetric group $ S_4 $) and this group is a maximal finite subgroup of rotations and indeed it turns out that adding any other rotation and taking the closure will generate all of $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{R})$.

The group of integer points is also maximal in $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb R) $. See the answer by YCor given to Is $SL_2(\mathbb Z)$ a maximal discrete subgroup in $SL_2(\mathbb R)$?.

Although this only states that $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb{Z}) $ is maximal among discrete subgroups I'm guessing that it is in fact maximal among closed subgroups as well in this case.

Is the group of integer points of a real linear algebraic group a maximal closed subgroup?

Let $ G $ be a simple linear algebraic group. Let $ G_\mathbb{R} $ be the real points of $ G $. Let $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ be the integer points of $ G $. Is $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ a maximal closed subgroup? In other words, are the only closed subgroups $ H $ of $ G_\mathbb{R} $ such that $$ G_\mathbb{Z} \subset H \subset G_\mathbb{R} $$ just $ G_\mathbb{R} $ and $ G_{\mathbb{Z}} $?

Integer points are in dense for $ \operatorname{SO}_3 $. $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{Z}) $ is the 24 element octohedral group (isomorphic to the symmetric group $ S_4 $) and this group is a maximal finite subgroup of rotations and indeed it turns out that adding any other rotation and taking the closure will generate all of $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{R})$.

The group of integer points is also maximal in $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb R) $. See the answer by YCor given to Is $SL_2(\mathbb Z)$ a maximal discrete subgroup in $SL_2(\mathbb R)$?.

Although this only states that $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb{Z}) $ is maximal among discrete subgroups I'm guessing that it is in fact maximal among closed subgroups as well in this case.

Is the group of integer points of a simple real linear algebraic group a maximal closed subgroup?

Let $ G $ be a simple linear algebraic group. Let $ G_\mathbb{R} $ be the real points of $ G $. Let $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ be the integer points of $ G $. Is $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ a maximal closed subgroup? In other words, are the only closed subgroups $ H $ of $ G_\mathbb{R} $ such that $$ G_\mathbb{Z} \subset H \subset G_\mathbb{R} $$ just $ G_\mathbb{R} $ and $ G_{\mathbb{Z}} $?

The answer is yes for for $SO_3$. $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{Z}) $ is the 24 element octohedral group (isomorphic to the symmetric group $ S_4 $) and this group is a maximal finite subgroup of rotations and indeed it turns out that adding any other rotation and taking the closure will generate all of $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{R})$.

The group of integer points is also maximal in $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb R) $. See the answer by YCor given to Is $SL_2(\mathbb Z)$ a maximal discrete subgroup in $SL_2(\mathbb R)$?.

Although this only states that $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb{Z}) $ is maximal among discrete subgroups I'm guessing that it is in fact maximal among closed subgroups as well in this case.

Became Hot Network Question
Proofreading; `\operatorname`
Source Link
LSpice
  • 12.9k
  • 4
  • 45
  • 69

Let $ G $ be a simple linear algebraic group. Let $ G_\mathbb{R} $ be the real points of $ G $. Let $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ be the integer points of $ G $. Is $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ a maximal closed subgroup? In other words, are the only closed subgroups $ H $ of $ G_\mathbb{R} $ such that $$ G_\mathbb{Z} \subset H \subset G_\mathbb{R} $$ just $ G_\mathbb{R} $ and $ G_{\mathbb{Z}} $?

Integer points are in dense for $ SO_3 $$ \operatorname{SO}_3 $. $ SO_3(\mathbb{Z}) $$ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{Z}) $ is the 24 element octohedral group ( isomorphicisomorphic to the symmetric group $ S_4 $  ) and this group is a maximal finite subgroup of rotations and indeed it turns out that adding any other rotation and taking the closure will generate all of $ SO_3(\mathbb{R})$$ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{R})$.

The group of integer points is also maximal in $ SL_n $$ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb R) $. See second answerthe answer by YcorYCor given here:

to https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/3388661/is-sl-2-mathbb-z-a-maximal-discrete-subgroup-in-sl-2-mathbb-rIs $SL_2(\mathbb Z)$ a maximal discrete subgroup in $SL_2(\mathbb R)$?.

Although this only states that $ SL_n(\mathbb{Z}) $$ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb{Z}) $ is maximal among discrete subgroups I'm guessing that it is in fact maximal among closed subgroups as well in this case.

Let $ G $ be a simple linear algebraic group. Let $ G_\mathbb{R} $ be the real points of $ G $. Let $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ be the integer points of $ G $. Is $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ a maximal closed subgroup? In other words, are the only closed subgroups $ H $ of $ G_\mathbb{R} $ such that $$ G_\mathbb{Z} \subset H \subset G_\mathbb{R} $$ just $ G_\mathbb{R} $ and $ G_{\mathbb{Z}} $?

Integer points are in dense for $ SO_3 $. $ SO_3(\mathbb{Z}) $ is the 24 element octohedral group ( isomorphic to the symmetric group $ S_4 $  ) and this group is a maximal finite subgroup of rotations and indeed it turns out that adding any other rotation and taking the closure will generate all of $ SO_3(\mathbb{R})$.

The group of integer points is also maximal in $ SL_n $. See second answer by Ycor given here:

https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/3388661/is-sl-2-mathbb-z-a-maximal-discrete-subgroup-in-sl-2-mathbb-r

Although this only states that $ SL_n(\mathbb{Z}) $ is maximal among discrete subgroups I'm guessing that it is in fact maximal among closed subgroups as well in this case.

Let $ G $ be a simple linear algebraic group. Let $ G_\mathbb{R} $ be the real points of $ G $. Let $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ be the integer points of $ G $. Is $ G_\mathbb{Z} $ a maximal closed subgroup? In other words, are the only closed subgroups $ H $ of $ G_\mathbb{R} $ such that $$ G_\mathbb{Z} \subset H \subset G_\mathbb{R} $$ just $ G_\mathbb{R} $ and $ G_{\mathbb{Z}} $?

Integer points are in dense for $ \operatorname{SO}_3 $. $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{Z}) $ is the 24 element octohedral group (isomorphic to the symmetric group $ S_4 $) and this group is a maximal finite subgroup of rotations and indeed it turns out that adding any other rotation and taking the closure will generate all of $ \operatorname{SO}_3(\mathbb{R})$.

The group of integer points is also maximal in $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb R) $. See the answer by YCor given to Is $SL_2(\mathbb Z)$ a maximal discrete subgroup in $SL_2(\mathbb R)$?.

Although this only states that $ \operatorname{SL}_n(\mathbb{Z}) $ is maximal among discrete subgroups I'm guessing that it is in fact maximal among closed subgroups as well in this case.

added 21 characters in body
Source Link
Loading
Source Link
Loading