Skip to main content
added 157 characters in body; edited tags; edited title
Source Link
Paul Taylor
  • 8.5k
  • 1
  • 29
  • 58

Is there any model of mathematics where there exists a What does overtness mean for metric space that is not overtspaces?

Original question: For compact metric spaces, plenty of subtly different definitions converge to the same concept. Overtness can be viewed as a property dual to compactness. So is there a similar story for overt metric spaces?

Edit: Since overtness is trivially true assuming the Law of the Excluded Middle, clearly the question is primarily interesting when we do not assume the LEM.

Edit 2: It looks like it is extremely difficult for a metric space to not be overt even in constructive settings. So editing the question to ask if there is ANY model where metric spaces are not overt.

Edit 3: For these reasons I changed the question again, from "Is there any model of mathematics where there exists a metric space that is not overt?". PT

Is there any model of mathematics where there exists a metric space that is not overt?

Original question: For compact metric spaces, plenty of subtly different definitions converge to the same concept. Overtness can be viewed as a property dual to compactness. So is there a similar story for overt metric spaces?

Edit: Since overtness is trivially true assuming the Law of the Excluded Middle, clearly the question is primarily interesting when we do not assume the LEM.

Edit 2: It looks like it is extremely difficult for a metric space to not be overt even in constructive settings. So editing the question to ask if there is ANY model where metric spaces are not overt.

What does overtness mean for metric spaces?

Original question: For compact metric spaces, plenty of subtly different definitions converge to the same concept. Overtness can be viewed as a property dual to compactness. So is there a similar story for overt metric spaces?

Edit: Since overtness is trivially true assuming the Law of the Excluded Middle, clearly the question is primarily interesting when we do not assume the LEM.

Edit 2: It looks like it is extremely difficult for a metric space to not be overt even in constructive settings. So editing the question to ask if there is ANY model where metric spaces are not overt.

Edit 3: For these reasons I changed the question again, from "Is there any model of mathematics where there exists a metric space that is not overt?". PT

Typo
Source Link
LSpice
  • 12.9k
  • 4
  • 45
  • 69

Original question: For compact metric spaces, plenty of subtly different definitions converge to the same concept. Overtness can be viewed aas a property dual to compactness. So is there a similar story for overt metric spaces?

Edit: Since overtness is trivially true assuming the Law of the Excluded Middle, clearly the question is primarily interesting when we do not assume the LEM.

Edit 2: It looks like it is extremely difficult for a metric space to not be overt even in constructive settings. So editing the question to ask if there is ANY model where metric spaces are not overt.

Original question: For compact metric spaces, plenty of subtly different definitions converge to the same concept. Overtness can be viewed a a property dual to compactness. So is there a similar story for overt metric spaces?

Edit: Since overtness is trivially true assuming the Law of the Excluded Middle, clearly the question is primarily interesting when we do not assume the LEM.

Edit 2: It looks like it is extremely difficult for a metric space to not be overt even in constructive settings. So editing the question to ask if there is ANY model where metric spaces are not overt.

Original question: For compact metric spaces, plenty of subtly different definitions converge to the same concept. Overtness can be viewed as a property dual to compactness. So is there a similar story for overt metric spaces?

Edit: Since overtness is trivially true assuming the Law of the Excluded Middle, clearly the question is primarily interesting when we do not assume the LEM.

Edit 2: It looks like it is extremely difficult for a metric space to not be overt even in constructive settings. So editing the question to ask if there is ANY model where metric spaces are not overt.

removed capitals
Source Link
YCor
  • 63.9k
  • 5
  • 187
  • 286

Is there any model of mathematics where there exists a metric space that is not Overtovert?

Original question: For compact metric spaces, plenty of subtly different definitions converge to the same concept. Overtness can be viewed a a property dual to compactness. So is there a similar story for overt metric spaces?

Edit: Since Overtnessovertness is trivially true assuming the Law of the Excluded Middle, clearly the question is primarily interesting when we do not assume the LEM.

Edit 2: It looks like it is extremely difficult for a metric space to not be overt even in constructive settings. So editing the question to ask if there is ANY model where metric spaces are not overt.

Is there any model of mathematics where there exists a metric space that is not Overt?

Original question: For compact metric spaces, plenty of subtly different definitions converge to the same concept. Overtness can be viewed a a property dual to compactness. So is there a similar story for overt metric spaces?

Edit: Since Overtness is trivially true assuming the Law of the Excluded Middle, clearly the question is primarily interesting when we do not assume the LEM.

Edit 2: It looks like it is extremely difficult for a metric space to not be overt even in constructive settings. So editing the question to ask if there is ANY model where metric spaces are not overt.

Is there any model of mathematics where there exists a metric space that is not overt?

Original question: For compact metric spaces, plenty of subtly different definitions converge to the same concept. Overtness can be viewed a a property dual to compactness. So is there a similar story for overt metric spaces?

Edit: Since overtness is trivially true assuming the Law of the Excluded Middle, clearly the question is primarily interesting when we do not assume the LEM.

Edit 2: It looks like it is extremely difficult for a metric space to not be overt even in constructive settings. So editing the question to ask if there is ANY model where metric spaces are not overt.

added 5 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
saolof
  • 1.9k
  • 6
  • 19
Loading
added 380 characters in body
Source Link
saolof
  • 1.9k
  • 6
  • 19
Loading
edited tags
Link
YCor
  • 63.9k
  • 5
  • 187
  • 286
Loading
Source Link
saolof
  • 1.9k
  • 6
  • 19
Loading