Skip to main content
added 175 characters in body
Source Link
Chris Woodward
  • 1.6k
  • 1
  • 11
  • 18

Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of a fiber product of maps assuming the fiber product is also a homotopy equivalence?

In more detail, suppose that $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$ are homotopy equivalences of (differentiable, say, compact oriented) manifolds. There is a long history of product formulae for surgery obstructions which includes a surgery obstruction for the product map $X \times Z \to Y \times Y$ to be homotopic to a homeomorphism. See for example Section 8 in Ranicki, Algebraic Theory of Surgery II. Applications to Topology.

Suppose I know that the fiber product $X \times_Y Z \to Y$ is also a homotopy equivalence. (Often it won't be, but in my case I got lucky.) Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of this map in terms of those of $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$? I am actually just interested in the case $X \times_Y X \to Y$, perturbed to make the fiber product transverse and would like to know what are the possibilities for the surgery obstruction of this map. (Could it be anything?)

Side question: It's interesting to compare the honest fiber product $X \times_Y Z $ with the homotopy fiber product $X \times_{Y,h} Z$; in my case they are homotopy equivalent. But I don't see any reason why $X \times_{Y,h} Z$ should admit a manifold structure in general. That is, Given $X,Y,Z$ homotopy equivalent as above, when is should one expect the homotopy fiber product $X \times_{Y,h} Z$ to admit a manifold structure?

Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of a fiber product of maps assuming the fiber product is also a homotopy equivalence?

In more detail, suppose that $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$ are homotopy equivalences of (differentiable, say, compact oriented) manifolds. There is a long history of product formulae for surgery obstructions which includes a surgery obstruction for the product map $X \times Z \to Y \times Y$ to be homotopic to a homeomorphism. See for example Section 8 in Ranicki, Algebraic Theory of Surgery II. Applications to Topology.

Suppose I know that the fiber product $X \times_Y Z \to Y$ is also a homotopy equivalence. (Often it won't be, but in my case I got lucky.) Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of this map in terms of those of $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$? I am actually just interested in the case $X \times_Y X \to Y$, perturbed to make the fiber product transverse and would like to know what are the possibilities for the surgery obstruction of this map. (Could it be anything?)

Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of a fiber product of maps assuming the fiber product is also a homotopy equivalence?

In more detail, suppose that $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$ are homotopy equivalences of (differentiable, say, compact oriented) manifolds. There is a long history of product formulae for surgery obstructions which includes a surgery obstruction for the product map $X \times Z \to Y \times Y$ to be homotopic to a homeomorphism. See for example Section 8 in Ranicki, Algebraic Theory of Surgery II. Applications to Topology.

Suppose I know that the fiber product $X \times_Y Z \to Y$ is also a homotopy equivalence. (Often it won't be, but in my case I got lucky.) Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of this map in terms of those of $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$? I am actually just interested in the case $X \times_Y X \to Y$, perturbed to make the fiber product transverse and would like to know what are the possibilities for the surgery obstruction of this map. (Could it be anything?)

Side question: It's interesting to compare the honest fiber product $X \times_Y Z $ with the homotopy fiber product $X \times_{Y,h} Z$; in my case they are homotopy equivalent. But I don't see any reason why $X \times_{Y,h} Z$ should admit a manifold structure in general. That is, Given $X,Y,Z$ homotopy equivalent as above, when is should one expect the homotopy fiber product $X \times_{Y,h} Z$ to admit a manifold structure?

added 3 characters in body
Source Link
Chris Woodward
  • 1.6k
  • 1
  • 11
  • 18

Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of a fiber product of maps assuming the fiber product is also a homotopy equivalence?

In more detail, suppose that $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$ are homotopy equivalences of (topologicaldifferentiable, say, compact oriented) manifolds. There is a long history of product formulae for surgery obstructions which includes a surgery obstruction for the product map $X \times Z \to Y \times Y$ to be homotopic to a homeomorphism. See for example Section 8 in Ranicki, Algebraic Theory of Surgery II. Applications to Topology.

Suppose I know that the fiber product $X \times_Y Z \to Y$ is also a homotopy equivalence. (Often it won't be, but in my case I got lucky.) Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of this map in terms of those of $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$? I am actually just interested in the case $X \times_Y X \to Y$, perturbed to make the fiber product transverse and would like to know what are the possibilities for the surgery obstruction of this map. (Could it be anything?)

Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of a fiber product of maps assuming the fiber product is also a homotopy equivalence?

In more detail, suppose that $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$ are homotopy equivalences of (topological, say, compact oriented) manifolds. There is a long history of product formulae for surgery obstructions which includes a surgery obstruction for the product map $X \times Z \to Y \times Y$ to be homotopic to a homeomorphism. See for example Section 8 in Ranicki, Algebraic Theory of Surgery II. Applications to Topology.

Suppose I know that the fiber product $X \times_Y Z \to Y$ is also a homotopy equivalence. (Often it won't be, but in my case I got lucky.) Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of this map in terms of those of $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$? I am actually just interested in the case $X \times_Y X \to Y$, perturbed to make the fiber product transverse and would like to know what are the possibilities for the surgery obstruction of this map. (Could it be anything?)

Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of a fiber product of maps assuming the fiber product is also a homotopy equivalence?

In more detail, suppose that $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$ are homotopy equivalences of (differentiable, say, compact oriented) manifolds. There is a long history of product formulae for surgery obstructions which includes a surgery obstruction for the product map $X \times Z \to Y \times Y$ to be homotopic to a homeomorphism. See for example Section 8 in Ranicki, Algebraic Theory of Surgery II. Applications to Topology.

Suppose I know that the fiber product $X \times_Y Z \to Y$ is also a homotopy equivalence. (Often it won't be, but in my case I got lucky.) Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of this map in terms of those of $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$? I am actually just interested in the case $X \times_Y X \to Y$, perturbed to make the fiber product transverse and would like to know what are the possibilities for the surgery obstruction of this map. (Could it be anything?)

Source Link
Chris Woodward
  • 1.6k
  • 1
  • 11
  • 18

Fiber product formulae for surgery obstructions

Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of a fiber product of maps assuming the fiber product is also a homotopy equivalence?

In more detail, suppose that $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$ are homotopy equivalences of (topological, say, compact oriented) manifolds. There is a long history of product formulae for surgery obstructions which includes a surgery obstruction for the product map $X \times Z \to Y \times Y$ to be homotopic to a homeomorphism. See for example Section 8 in Ranicki, Algebraic Theory of Surgery II. Applications to Topology.

Suppose I know that the fiber product $X \times_Y Z \to Y$ is also a homotopy equivalence. (Often it won't be, but in my case I got lucky.) Is there a formula for the surgery obstruction of this map in terms of those of $X \to Y$ and $Z \to Y$? I am actually just interested in the case $X \times_Y X \to Y$, perturbed to make the fiber product transverse and would like to know what are the possibilities for the surgery obstruction of this map. (Could it be anything?)