Skip to main content
Commonmark migration
Source Link

It is well-known that any two great circles intersects on a sphere. In fact, there are infinitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere with a common intersection. Intuitively, it seems to me that there is only finitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere if one do not allow intersection.

I try to investigate this by considering stereographic projection. enter image description here

I came up with the above picture in which the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge on a plane correspond to the three geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ on the sphere. Since there is no intersection among the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge, the three geodesics do not intersect either.

In other words, this picture shows that $3$ geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection. In particular, this implies that $3$ half great circles can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection.

If one draw the fourth circle on top of the three, it seems impossible to draw a fourth edge on the circle which corresponds to a geodesic of length $\ge \pi$ on the sphere.

Conjecture:

 

The maximum number of half great circles can be drawn on a sphere is $3$ if one do not allow intersection.

 

How to prove/disprove this conjecture rigorously?

It is well-known that any two great circles intersects on a sphere. In fact, there are infinitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere with a common intersection. Intuitively, it seems to me that there is only finitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere if one do not allow intersection.

I try to investigate this by considering stereographic projection. enter image description here

I came up with the above picture in which the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge on a plane correspond to the three geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ on the sphere. Since there is no intersection among the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge, the three geodesics do not intersect either.

In other words, this picture shows that $3$ geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection. In particular, this implies that $3$ half great circles can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection.

If one draw the fourth circle on top of the three, it seems impossible to draw a fourth edge on the circle which corresponds to a geodesic of length $\ge \pi$ on the sphere.

Conjecture:

 

The maximum number of half great circles can be drawn on a sphere is $3$ if one do not allow intersection.

 

How to prove/disprove this conjecture rigorously?

It is well-known that any two great circles intersects on a sphere. In fact, there are infinitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere with a common intersection. Intuitively, it seems to me that there is only finitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere if one do not allow intersection.

I try to investigate this by considering stereographic projection. enter image description here

I came up with the above picture in which the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge on a plane correspond to the three geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ on the sphere. Since there is no intersection among the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge, the three geodesics do not intersect either.

In other words, this picture shows that $3$ geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection. In particular, this implies that $3$ half great circles can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection.

If one draw the fourth circle on top of the three, it seems impossible to draw a fourth edge on the circle which corresponds to a geodesic of length $\ge \pi$ on the sphere.

Conjecture:

The maximum number of half great circles can be drawn on a sphere is $3$ if one do not allow intersection.

How to prove/disprove this conjecture rigorously?

added 177 characters in body
Source Link
James Cheung
  • 1.9k
  • 9
  • 10

It is well-known that any two great circles intersects on a sphere. In fact, there are infinitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere with a common intersection. Intuitively, it seems to me that there is only finitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere if one do not allow intersection.

I try to investigate this by considering stereographic projection. enter image description here

I came up with the above picture in which the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge on a plane correspond to the three geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ on the sphere. Since there is no intersection among the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge, the three geodesics do not intersect either.

In other words, this picture shows that $3$ geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection. In particular, this implies that $3$ half great circles can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection.

If one draw the fourth circle on top of the three, it seems impossible to draw a fourth edge on the circle which corresponds to a geodesic of length $\ge \pi$ on the sphere.

Conjecture:

The maximum number of half great circles can be drawn on a sphere is $3$ if one do not allow intersection.

How to prove/disprove this conjecture rigorously?

It is well-known that any two great circles intersects on a sphere. In fact, there are infinitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere with a common intersection. Intuitively, it seems to me that there is only finitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere if one do not allow intersection.

I try to investigate this by considering stereographic projection. enter image description here

I came up with the above picture in which the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge on a plane correspond to the three geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ on the sphere. Since there is no intersection among the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge, the three geodesics do not intersect either.

In other words, this picture shows that $3$ geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection. In particular, this implies that $3$ half great circles can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection.

Conjecture:

The maximum number of half great circles can be drawn on a sphere is $3$ if one do not allow intersection.

How to prove/disprove this conjecture rigorously?

It is well-known that any two great circles intersects on a sphere. In fact, there are infinitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere with a common intersection. Intuitively, it seems to me that there is only finitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere if one do not allow intersection.

I try to investigate this by considering stereographic projection. enter image description here

I came up with the above picture in which the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge on a plane correspond to the three geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ on the sphere. Since there is no intersection among the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge, the three geodesics do not intersect either.

In other words, this picture shows that $3$ geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection. In particular, this implies that $3$ half great circles can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection.

If one draw the fourth circle on top of the three, it seems impossible to draw a fourth edge on the circle which corresponds to a geodesic of length $\ge \pi$ on the sphere.

Conjecture:

The maximum number of half great circles can be drawn on a sphere is $3$ if one do not allow intersection.

How to prove/disprove this conjecture rigorously?

Source Link
James Cheung
  • 1.9k
  • 9
  • 10

Maximum number of half great circles of length $\pi$ can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection

It is well-known that any two great circles intersects on a sphere. In fact, there are infinitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere with a common intersection. Intuitively, it seems to me that there is only finitely many half great circles can be drawn on a sphere if one do not allow intersection.

I try to investigate this by considering stereographic projection. enter image description here

I came up with the above picture in which the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge on a plane correspond to the three geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ on the sphere. Since there is no intersection among the yellow edge, blue edge and red edge, the three geodesics do not intersect either.

In other words, this picture shows that $3$ geodesics of length $\ge \pi$ can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection. In particular, this implies that $3$ half great circles can be drawn on a sphere without any intersection.

Conjecture:

The maximum number of half great circles can be drawn on a sphere is $3$ if one do not allow intersection.

How to prove/disprove this conjecture rigorously?