Skip to main content
added 2 characters in body
Source Link
Glorfindel
  • 2.8k
  • 6
  • 28
  • 38

I have been asked sometimes, and I ask myself, to what extent the dimension $1+3$ is important for our real world, say compared to an hypothetichypothetical $(1+d)$-dimensional world. I have two answers in mind.

  • The HuyghensHuygens principle. If you switch off a point source of light, then a point situated at distance $L$ will be in dark after time $\delta t=L/c$ ($c$ the speed of light). This would be false in dimension $1+2$ for instance, even if the energy would be very low after $\delta t$.
  • Chemistry is a consequence of quantum mechanics. Mathematically it involves the linear representations of the rotation group. In $1+2$ dimensions, the group is $SO_2$, which is abelian and isomorphic to a circle ; its representations are one-dimensional, associated with linear characters. In our world, the groups $SO_3$ is not abelian and the situation is way richer. In particular, we have a notion of spin.

What are other manifestations of the dimension $1+3$ in our real world ?

In order to limit this discussion to a reasonnablereasonable extent, I assume that the Physics of a hypothetichypothetical world would be based on equations similar to those we already know. In particular, second-order differential operators would be at stake, because of their nice mathematical properties (maximum principle, ...)

I have been asked sometimes, and I ask myself, to what extent the dimension $1+3$ is important for our real world, say compared to an hypothetic $(1+d)$-dimensional world. I have two answers in mind.

  • The Huyghens principle. If you switch off a point source of light, then a point situated at distance $L$ will be in dark after time $\delta t=L/c$ ($c$ the speed of light). This would be false in dimension $1+2$ for instance, even if the energy would be very low after $\delta t$.
  • Chemistry is a consequence of quantum mechanics. Mathematically it involves the linear representations of the rotation group. In $1+2$ dimensions, the group is $SO_2$, which is abelian and isomorphic to a circle ; its representations are one-dimensional, associated with linear characters. In our world, the groups $SO_3$ is not abelian and the situation is way richer. In particular, we have a notion of spin.

What are other manifestations of the dimension $1+3$ in our real world ?

In order to limit this discussion to a reasonnable extent, I assume that the Physics of a hypothetic world would be based on equations similar to those we already know. In particular, second-order differential operators would be at stake, because of their nice mathematical properties (maximum principle, ...)

I have been asked sometimes, and I ask myself, to what extent the dimension $1+3$ is important for our real world, say compared to an hypothetical $(1+d)$-dimensional world. I have two answers in mind.

  • The Huygens principle. If you switch off a point source of light, then a point situated at distance $L$ will be in dark after time $\delta t=L/c$ ($c$ the speed of light). This would be false in dimension $1+2$ for instance, even if the energy would be very low after $\delta t$.
  • Chemistry is a consequence of quantum mechanics. Mathematically it involves the linear representations of the rotation group. In $1+2$ dimensions, the group is $SO_2$, which is abelian and isomorphic to a circle ; its representations are one-dimensional, associated with linear characters. In our world, the groups $SO_3$ is not abelian and the situation is way richer. In particular, we have a notion of spin.

What are other manifestations of the dimension $1+3$ in our real world ?

In order to limit this discussion to a reasonable extent, I assume that the Physics of a hypothetical world would be based on equations similar to those we already know. In particular, second-order differential operators would be at stake, because of their nice mathematical properties (maximum principle, ...)

Source Link
Denis Serre
  • 52.3k
  • 10
  • 146
  • 300

The specificity of dimension $1+3$ for the real world

I have been asked sometimes, and I ask myself, to what extent the dimension $1+3$ is important for our real world, say compared to an hypothetic $(1+d)$-dimensional world. I have two answers in mind.

  • The Huyghens principle. If you switch off a point source of light, then a point situated at distance $L$ will be in dark after time $\delta t=L/c$ ($c$ the speed of light). This would be false in dimension $1+2$ for instance, even if the energy would be very low after $\delta t$.
  • Chemistry is a consequence of quantum mechanics. Mathematically it involves the linear representations of the rotation group. In $1+2$ dimensions, the group is $SO_2$, which is abelian and isomorphic to a circle ; its representations are one-dimensional, associated with linear characters. In our world, the groups $SO_3$ is not abelian and the situation is way richer. In particular, we have a notion of spin.

What are other manifestations of the dimension $1+3$ in our real world ?

In order to limit this discussion to a reasonnable extent, I assume that the Physics of a hypothetic world would be based on equations similar to those we already know. In particular, second-order differential operators would be at stake, because of their nice mathematical properties (maximum principle, ...)