Skip to main content
Fix grammar a little bit
Source Link

By a curve I mean an integral one-dimensional scheme of finite type over a spectrum of a field.

Let $C$ be a curve over an arbitrary field $k$. It's probably a very well known fact, that $C$ is rational over $k$, if and only if $C$ is rational over any field extension $L/k$. I'm wondering, if there an elementary proof of this property.

The easiest argument I can think about at this moment, is to choose a smooth projective curve $\overline{C}\subset\mathbb{P}_k^n$ birational to $C$ and observe, that it's Hilbert polynomial does not depend on base extension $L/k$. This is a consequence of the fact that $L$ is a flat $k$-module. Therefore, the arithmetic genus of $C$ does not depend on base extension. Finally, by Bézout theorem and the genus formula, one can verify that arithmetic genus equal to zero implies that there exist a $k$-parametrization $\mathbb{P}_k^1\longrightarrow\overline{C}$.

All this said, I believe that there should exist a shorter and more algebraic argument. However, I can't find one. I will be grateful for any peacepiece of advice.

EDIT As @Abhinav and pointed out in his answer below, the resultstatement is not even true in general. On the other handLuckily for me, it holds true as long as the field extension $L/k$ is pure transcendental (see the answer of @Pete L. Clark below), which is good enough for the applications I was thinking about. Thank you! :)

By a curve I mean an integral one-dimensional scheme of finite type over a spectrum of a field.

Let $C$ be a curve over an arbitrary field $k$. It's probably a very well known fact, that $C$ is rational over $k$, if and only if $C$ is rational over any field extension $L/k$. I'm wondering, if there an elementary proof of this property.

The easiest argument I can think about at this moment, is to choose a smooth projective curve $\overline{C}\subset\mathbb{P}_k^n$ birational to $C$ and observe, that it's Hilbert polynomial does not depend on base extension $L/k$. This is a consequence of the fact that $L$ is a flat $k$-module. Therefore, the arithmetic genus of $C$ does not depend on base extension. Finally, by Bézout theorem and the genus formula, one can verify that arithmetic genus equal to zero implies that there exist a $k$-parametrization $\mathbb{P}_k^1\longrightarrow\overline{C}$.

All this said, I believe that there should exist a shorter and more algebraic argument. However, I can't find one. I will be grateful for any peace of advice.

EDIT As @Abhinav and pointed out in his answer below, the result is not true in general. On the other hand, it holds true as long as the field extension $L/k$ is pure transcendental (see the answer of @Pete L. Clark below), which is good enough for the applications I was thinking about. Thank you! :)

By a curve I mean an integral one-dimensional scheme of finite type over a spectrum of a field.

Let $C$ be a curve over an arbitrary field $k$. It's probably a very well known fact, that $C$ is rational over $k$, if and only if $C$ is rational over any field extension $L/k$. I'm wondering, if there an elementary proof of this property.

The easiest argument I can think about at this moment, is to choose a smooth projective curve $\overline{C}\subset\mathbb{P}_k^n$ birational to $C$ and observe, that it's Hilbert polynomial does not depend on base extension $L/k$. This is a consequence of the fact that $L$ is a flat $k$-module. Therefore, the arithmetic genus of $C$ does not depend on base extension. Finally, by Bézout theorem and the genus formula, one can verify that arithmetic genus equal to zero implies that there exist a $k$-parametrization $\mathbb{P}_k^1\longrightarrow\overline{C}$.

All this said, I believe that there should exist a shorter and more algebraic argument. However, I can't find one. I will be grateful for any piece of advice.

EDIT As @Abhinav pointed out in his answer below, the statement is not even true in general. Luckily for me, it holds true as long as the field extension $L/k$ is pure transcendental (see the answer of @Pete L. Clark below), which is good enough for the applications I was thinking about. Thank you! :)

added summary
Source Link

By a curve I mean an integral one-dimensional scheme of finite type over a spectrum of a field.

Let $C$ be a curve over an arbitrary field $k$. It's probably a very well known fact, that $C$ is rational over $k$, if and only if $C$ is rational over any field extension $L/k$. I'm wondering, if there an elementary proof of this property.

The easiest argument I can think about at this moment, is to choose a smooth projective curve $\overline{C}\subset\mathbb{P}_k^n$ birational to $C$ and observe, that it's Hilbert polynomial does not depend on base extension $L/k$. This is a consequence of the fact that $L$ is a flat $k$-module. Therefore, the arithmetic genus of $C$ does not depend on base extension. Finally, by Bézout theorem and the genus formula, one can verify that arithmetic genus equal to zero implies that there exist a $k$-parametrization $\mathbb{P}_k^1\longrightarrow\overline{C}$.

All this said, I belivebelieve that there should exist a shorter and more algebraic argument. However, I can't find one. I will be grateful for any peace of advice.

EDIT As @Abhinav and pointed out in his answer below, the result is not true in general. On the other hand, it holds true as long as the field extension $L/k$ is pure transcendental (see the answer of @Pete L. Clark below), which is good enough for the applications I was thinking about. Thank you! :)

By a curve I mean an integral one-dimensional scheme of finite type over a spectrum of a field.

Let $C$ be a curve over an arbitrary field $k$. It's probably a very well known fact, that $C$ is rational over $k$, if and only if $C$ is rational over any field extension $L/k$. I'm wondering, if there an elementary proof of this property.

The easiest argument I can think about at this moment, is to choose a smooth projective curve $\overline{C}\subset\mathbb{P}_k^n$ birational to $C$ and observe, that it's Hilbert polynomial does not depend on base extension $L/k$. This is a consequence of the fact that $L$ is a flat $k$-module. Therefore, the arithmetic genus of $C$ does not depend on base extension. Finally, by Bézout theorem and the genus formula, one can verify that arithmetic genus equal to zero implies that there exist a $k$-parametrization $\mathbb{P}_k^1\longrightarrow\overline{C}$.

All this said, I belive that there should exist a shorter and more algebraic argument. However, I can't find one. I will be grateful for any peace of advice.

By a curve I mean an integral one-dimensional scheme of finite type over a spectrum of a field.

Let $C$ be a curve over an arbitrary field $k$. It's probably a very well known fact, that $C$ is rational over $k$, if and only if $C$ is rational over any field extension $L/k$. I'm wondering, if there an elementary proof of this property.

The easiest argument I can think about at this moment, is to choose a smooth projective curve $\overline{C}\subset\mathbb{P}_k^n$ birational to $C$ and observe, that it's Hilbert polynomial does not depend on base extension $L/k$. This is a consequence of the fact that $L$ is a flat $k$-module. Therefore, the arithmetic genus of $C$ does not depend on base extension. Finally, by Bézout theorem and the genus formula, one can verify that arithmetic genus equal to zero implies that there exist a $k$-parametrization $\mathbb{P}_k^1\longrightarrow\overline{C}$.

All this said, I believe that there should exist a shorter and more algebraic argument. However, I can't find one. I will be grateful for any peace of advice.

EDIT As @Abhinav and pointed out in his answer below, the result is not true in general. On the other hand, it holds true as long as the field extension $L/k$ is pure transcendental (see the answer of @Pete L. Clark below), which is good enough for the applications I was thinking about. Thank you! :)

Source Link

Rationality of curve does not depend on base change

By a curve I mean an integral one-dimensional scheme of finite type over a spectrum of a field.

Let $C$ be a curve over an arbitrary field $k$. It's probably a very well known fact, that $C$ is rational over $k$, if and only if $C$ is rational over any field extension $L/k$. I'm wondering, if there an elementary proof of this property.

The easiest argument I can think about at this moment, is to choose a smooth projective curve $\overline{C}\subset\mathbb{P}_k^n$ birational to $C$ and observe, that it's Hilbert polynomial does not depend on base extension $L/k$. This is a consequence of the fact that $L$ is a flat $k$-module. Therefore, the arithmetic genus of $C$ does not depend on base extension. Finally, by Bézout theorem and the genus formula, one can verify that arithmetic genus equal to zero implies that there exist a $k$-parametrization $\mathbb{P}_k^1\longrightarrow\overline{C}$.

All this said, I belive that there should exist a shorter and more algebraic argument. However, I can't find one. I will be grateful for any peace of advice.