Skip to main content
Qfwfq's user avatar
Qfwfq's user avatar
Qfwfq's user avatar
Qfwfq
  • Member for 14 years, 9 months
  • Last seen this week
comment
Why do we teach calculus students the derivative as a limit?
(...) In my own experience, in high school (second year) we defined real numbers by Dedekind cuts (a construction easily forgotten and immediately replaced by intuitive use of the usual properties! But we were told exactly what $\sqrt{2}$ is in that framework). Then in the fifth year of high school real analysis was done pretty rigorously including epsilon-deltas, continuity, derivatives, fundamental theorem of calculus (but with Riemann integral done with no proofs and with only semi-rigorous definition; and no mention of Cauchy sequences).
comment
Why do we teach calculus students the derivative as a limit?
@Steven Landsburg : we're probably using different definitions of "freshman calculus". In some countries this not-yet-rigorous version of elementary real analysis simply doesn't exist: people learn to deal with all the rigorous definitions and all the proofs from the get go. There, every freshman is supposed to get that knowledge of epsilon-deltas etc during "calculus" because "calculus" is done that way. So the question is probably location-dependent. (...)
awarded
comment
Physicist's request for intuition on covariant derivatives and Lie derivatives
@Ziad H. Muhammad: you're right. In fact this was pointed out in comments to my answer below. I didn't realize there was still that comment of mine here (that I've now deleted).
revised
Loading…
comment
"The boat is not longer than it is."
@Dave L Renfro: maybe he would've said: "I see your Schwartz is as big as mine"...
comment
For which smooth varieties is the Jacobian conjecture known to be true?
@Angelo: you weren't thinking of Ax-Grothendieck as the easy step, were you?
comment
For which smooth varieties is the Jacobian conjecture known to be true?
I must be missing something. Are you saying $f(X)$ has to be a projective variety? But $X$ isn't nec. projective
comment
For which smooth varieties is the Jacobian conjecture known to be true?
I figured ZMT (stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/05K0) implies $f$ is an open embedding. How can one easily see that $f$ is also surjective?
comment
For which smooth varieties is the Jacobian conjecture known to be true?
Yes, of course you're right: I meant $x\mapsto 2x$.
comment
For which smooth varieties is the Jacobian conjecture known to be true?
I wouldn't count Abelian varieties as interesting counterexamples in this context, because they always admit the $x\mapsto -x$ isogeny, so they trivially do not satisfy (RP) or (JC).
revised
Loading…
Loading…
awarded
revised
Categorical-geometric Langlands for tori
deleted 9 characters in body
Loading…
comment
Are rigid-analytic spaces obsolete, since adic spaces exist?
[I changed "if" to "since" in the title. Of course I'm ok with you reverting back the edit, if you deem appropriate]
revised
Loading…
revised
Loading…
comment
Low dimensional noncommutative non-cocommutative Hopf algebras
By "dimension" is it meant the dimension of $A$ as a vector space over the base field, or the dimension of the corresponding "quantum group" (if the latter makes sense..)?
comment
Why torsion is important in (co)homology ?
@Ryan Budney: You mean like in this question? mathoverflow.net/questions/34484/sheaf-cohomology-and-torsio‌​n - An answer sketching these other aspects could be interesting.
1
4 5
6
7 8
150