Stack Exchange network consists of 183 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers.
If you work for a while in the belief that an object with certain properties should exist, and eventually learn otherwise, then you will have discovered that the set of such objects is empty. I just now gave an MO answer of this type! mathoverflow.net/a/376107/2926
@adamC If you want to delete, there's a button for that. If you can't use it for some reason, we can delete it for you. But please don't do it by manually destroying content.
@YemonChoi By my reading, the students were not professionals, unless by "professional" one includes "intending to become a professional" (and how would one know that?). Actually, I am conflicted about calling Egan an "amateur" -- to me he walks and quacks just like a professional.
The last name is Hartogs, and I have changed the possessive to fit the OP's orthographic preference, although I would prefer Hartogs's for greater clarity