Skip to main content
Todd Trimble's user avatar
Todd Trimble's user avatar
Todd Trimble's user avatar
Todd Trimble
  • Member for 15 years, 2 months
  • Last seen this week
comment
What is famous mistake made by Feller?
Can you link to the lecture?
comment
trace(xy)=trace(yx) in full generality
@LSpice Thanks! I edited it in.
revised
trace(xy)=trace(yx) in full generality
repaired a broken link, h/t to LSpice
Loading…
comment
Techniques for debugging proofs
Hear, hear to the second. That's a trick I use when refereeing: look for those "clearly"s.
awarded
awarded
comment
Arithmetic theorems explainable to a high schooler using $\infty$-category theory in a crucial way
I'd say that $(\infty, n)$-category theory is still pretty young, and you shouldn't expect it as of today to solve problems explainable to high-school students that are beyond the reach of old established fields like algebraic number theory and algebraic geometry. Let's be clear not to mythologize higher category theory as blowing other powerful fields out of the water, at least not yet.
comment
Is there something similar to Lawvere-Tierney topologies for Abelian categories?
More search terms: Gabriel topology on an abelian category, universal closure operator.
comment
Is there something similar to Lawvere-Tierney topologies for Abelian categories?
I don't have time at the moment to give much more than a cursory reply, but a good search term might be "torsion theory". The nLab article ncatlab.org/nlab/show/torsion+theory has some material and references to get you started.
comment
Is a come back to mathematical research possible?
I started teaching again, and being part of an institution makes certain aspects of doing research a lot easier (I found).
comment
Connected posets $P\not \cong Q$ such that $\text{Hom}(P,P) \cong \text{Hom}(Q,Q)$
I think it would be a very nice gesture to inform the reader of what you already know about this problem, to avoid having people waste time. For instance, you are mentioned in a footnote here, arxiv.org/pdf/2005.03255.pdf, which recalls the finite case covered by results of Duffus and Wille.
awarded
Loading…
comment
Examples of common false beliefs in mathematics
An excellent answer. I hope the following works as an explicit example of the phenomenon: let $Y$ be an uncountable set, and let $X$ be countably infinite. Let $I$ be the directed set of finite subsets $F$ of $Y$, ordered by inclusion. For each finite subset $F$, let $E_F$ be the set of injective functions $\phi: F \to X$. For $F' \subseteq F$, the transition map $E_F \to E_{F'}$ is given by restriction. These maps are easily seen to be surjective. But if there were an element $(\phi_F)$ of the inverse limit, then we could manufacture an injective map $f:Y \to X$ by $f(y) = \phi_{\{y\}}(y)$.
comment
Examples of common false beliefs in mathematics
@PrinceM I'm impressed! Stay strong.
comment
Examples of common false beliefs in mathematics
It would be common only for complete noobs to functional analysis.
comment
Examples of common false beliefs in mathematics
@SamuelAdrianAntz Here's what I have. For any given rational $q$, suppose $r$ is a rational root of $x^3 - 5x -q$. After a long division, we conclude $x^3 - 5x - q = (x-r)(x^2 + rx + (r^2 - 5))$. The discriminant of the quadratic factor is $D = r^2 - 4(r^2-5) = 20 - 3r^2$, and another rational root of $x^3 - 5x - q$ exists only if $D$ is a rational square. So it suffices to show that there are no rational solutions $(r, s)$ to $3r^2 + s^2 = 20$. For this, show there are no integer solutions to $3r^2 + s^2 = 5t^2$ (except $(r,s,t)=(0,0,0)$). This boils down to simple modular arithmetic.
comment
Formula for the left adjoint of the nerve functor?
It sounds like you want to say in your first sentence "left adjoint of the nerve functor from the category of (small) categories to the category of simplicial sets". Yes, the fact that the counit of the first adjunction is an isomorphism is correct; that follows from full faithfulness of the nerve functor, as you point out. The singularization functor from topological spaces to simplicial sets is not fully faithful, so the counit of that adjunction will not be an isomorphism.
comment
Accessible functors not preserving lots of presentable objects
In answer to Mike's question in his comment, and following on Dap's comment on cofinality, I'd mention König’s theorem ncatlab.org/nlab/show/K%C3%B6nig%27s+theorem.
revised
Group action on fibre functor
link back to MathSE post
Loading…
1
9 10
11
12 13
313