Skip to main content
Paul Fabel's user avatar
Paul Fabel's user avatar
Paul Fabel's user avatar
Paul Fabel
  • Member for 13 years, 4 months
  • Last seen this week
  • Mississippi State University
answered
Loading…
awarded
awarded
awarded
revised
Loading…
comment
Are the higher homotopy groups of the Hawaiian earring trivial?
If A and C are disjoint, K =1 suffices, and this is provable by induction on the number of segments comprising A and B. If A and C are not disjoint, let D denote the intersection. Let A=A1*DA2 and C=C1*DC2. The diameter of the planar projection of Ai is at most that of Ci. Hence K=3 is an upper bound on the ratio of diameters of the planar projections of A and C.
comment
Are the higher homotopy groups of the Hawaiian earring trivial?
It is more straightforward to see K=3 is a universal upper bound. Let $Q$ denote the universal cover of $P$. Note $Q$ is CAT(0). Take any two geodesics segments A and B in $Q$. In $Q$, naturally project A into B. Call the image C. Now map A and C naturally into the plane and compare the ratios of the their diameters, using absolute value.
comment
Are the higher homotopy groups of the Hawaiian earring trivial?
There is a genuine gap since K=1.5 can actually happen. Place the letter V in the upper half plane with vertex at (0,0) and angles 60 degrees with w.r.t. x axis. Now place a different V with origin vertex, with angles 30 degrees and very long edges. Now project orthogonally the first V into the 2nd V while fixing the origin. This is purportedly the worst case, yielding a kind of poor man's Gehring-Hayman Theorem.
Loading…
revised
US does not imply AB
added 41 characters in body
Loading…
answered
Loading…
comment
revised
Loading…
revised
Loading…
comment
Loading…
comment
comment
Is every T0 2nd countable space the quotient of a separable metric space?
The relevance of the question is a `yes' answer would characterize T_0 qcb spaces (quotients of 2nd countable spaces), as quotients of separable metric spaces, since sequential spaces are precisely the quotients of a metrizable spaces, and since 2nd countable spaces are sequential, as noted in the question. Basic properties of qcb spaces are not obvious: mathematik.tu-darmstadt.de/~streicher/GrSt.pdf.
comment
Is every T0 2nd countable space the quotient of a separable metric space?
Francois, was hoping you'd see the question! Thanks!
1
3 4
5
6 7