Stack Exchange network consists of 183 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers.
Is there a version of Ore's theorem that applies to duo semigroups that are cancellative only on one side (that is, left or right cancellative)? In other words, if a duo semigroup is left or right cancellative, then is it cancellative (on both sides)? I will eventually ask a separate question on this, unless the answer turns out to be 'trivial'.
By the way, YCor's answer can be used to prove that a cancellative semigroup need not be a subdirect product of subdirectly irreducible cancellative semigroups, see mathoverflow.net/questions/480364#480364
@YCor I'm aware that group theorists tend to use the term 'bi-ordered' to mean 'totally ordered'. However, in other fields (including semigroup theory), 'ordered' is often used to mean 'partially bi-ordered'; otherwise, qualifiers like 'left' and 'right' are used, followed by terms such as 'orderable', 'totally ordered', etc. (see, for instance, Chap. 11 in the 2005 edition of Blyth's Lattices and Ordered Algebraic Structures). That's one reason why I included the definition of 'totally ordered' in my answer.
I have the impression that the "extension lemma" in this answer holds for every duo sgrp S that embeds into its own universal group G (regardless of whether G is totally orderable and S is the associated positive cone), one key point being that, by duoness, $g^{-1}hg\in S$ for all $g,h\in S$. Here, duo means that aS = Sa for every a ∈ S. This begs another question: mathoverflow.net/q/480390/16537
@YCor That $S$ is subdirectly irreducible is a consequence of the main theorem (which, in the meanwhile, was reformulated). That being said, I agree with Benjamin Steinberg's previous comments: I thought I had specified that $S$ is the same type of semigroup as in YCor's construction, but the truth is that I had forgotten. (I deleted some of my previous comments to tidy up the comment section.)