Skip to main content
HJRW's user avatar
HJRW's user avatar
HJRW's user avatar
HJRW
  • Member for 15 years, 1 month
  • Last seen this week
comment
Periods and commas in mathematical writing
And my point is that if I'm reading a sentence and I don't eventually encounter a full stop then I get confused, regardless of the mathematics. If the mathematics is so complicated that it interrupts the flow of your sentence, then you shouldn't include it in the sentence.
comment
Periods and commas in mathematical writing
@Sam, Sure. Actually, I think even trying to include commutative diagrams in sentences is doomed to failure. So I might have rephrased your example as: "Therefore, the following diagram commutes. <diagram> The diagram has no punctuation." Or something like that.
comment
Periods and commas in mathematical writing
In the latter situation, I'd follow Kingsley Amis's maxim: "Recast your sentence!" If there's no sensible place for the correct punctuation, then you have written a bad sentence.
comment
Periods and commas in mathematical writing
A sentence without a full stop always jars.
comment
Convex hull in CAT(0)
I seem to be getting wildly varying ratings for this answer! Perhaps I should comment that, when I wrote it, Anton had not specifically stated that he isn't interested in the proper case.
answered
Loading…
answered
Loading…
comment
The ants-on-a-ball problem
How are you extending your vector field over the disc without introducing zeros in the interior?
comment
Fundamental group of 3-manifold with boundary
A less intelligent but more simple-minded algorithm is just to apply geometrization and deduce that the word problem is (uniformly) solvable in 3-manifold groups. If you know how to solve the word problem then it's easy to tell if a group is trivial.
comment
A single paper everyone should read?
The bit I like is:- "If he patches up all these points, he will have proved the Poincare Conjecture (for we shall show how Theorem 0 for n=2 implies the Poincare Conjecture) incorrectly."
comment
When is a Hausdorff space metrisable?
Fair point. I suppose by a full answer I meant an equivalent condition to metrisability that doesn't use the notion of metrisability anywhere (eg in locally metrisable). I think that the condition provided by Jones' Theorem is necessary and sufficient (subject to some assumption about the Continuum Hypothesis).
answered
Loading…
awarded
revised
Circle bundles over $RP^2$
added 166 characters in body
Loading…
comment
Circle bundles over $RP^2$
Yes, DC just pointed this out to me. My mistake!
revised
Fundamental group of 3-manifold with boundary
Added reference to Scott's Theorem,
Loading…
revised
Circle bundles over $RP^2$
Introduced sharp
Loading…
accepted
comment
Factoring maps of handlebodies
Excellent! I think this is the best possible statement I could have hoped for.
answered
Loading…