"What's one class that mathematics that should be offered to undergraduates that isn't usually?"

OK, I'll rephrase my earlier answer.  A class that should be offered to undergraduates that usually isn't is a "what is mathematics" course for those liberal-arts majors who will take only one math course in their post-secondary schooling.  It would be a truthful course that would avoid telling them that mathematics consists memorizing algorithms whose utility can be seen only by taking later courses that they won't take.  It would acquaint them with the fact that mathematics, like physics, is a subject in which new discoveries are constantly being made.  It would tell them that one doesn't generally do math by taking a problem and feeding it into an algorithm that was given to one by a prophet who came down from Mount Sinai.  It would tell them that mathematics is a subject that, like music, relies heavily on technical skills but does not consist of those alone.  Among the goals would be that a student who takes only that course and becomes a professor of some liberal arts subject would not be among the many such professors who don't suspect the existence of such a field as mathematics.