False belief: A function being continuous in some open interval implies that it is also differentiable in that interval:

Counterexample:

The Weierstrass function is an example of a function that is continuous everywhere but differentiable nowhere:

$f(x) = \sum_{n=0}^\infty a^n cos(b^n \pi x)$

Where $a \in (0, 1)$, $b$ is a positive odd integer, and $ab > 1 + \frac{3\pi}{2}$.  The function has fractal-like behavior, which leads to it not being differentiable.  This notion is rather disheartening to most calculus students, though!

Another example that is maybe not a false belief so much as something that is very hard to believe at first is the Monty Hall problem.  I remember spending most of a day in catatonic despair when I first learned of it...