Amplitwist's solution just with Jordan: Consider the curves on the Riemann sphere $S$ and connect $\pm 1$ along the real interval $R$ inside the disk such that  $R \cup B$ is a closed curve on $S$. Then $A$ is a curve connecting inside and outside of   $R \cup B$ and thus intersects $R \cup B$ by Jordan curve theorem, but not inside the disk on $R$. Therefore $A$ and $B$ must intersect.

*Update:*   $i$ and $-i$ are on different sides of $R\cup B$ because the straight line $[-i,i] \subset D$ intersects $R$ exactly once and does not intersect $B$.