Let $\gamma\colon[a,b]\to \mathbb R^3$ be a smooth curve with curvature $< 1$. Consider a tube, formed by one parameter family of unit circles with center at $\gamma(t)$ in the plane orthogonal to $\dot\gamma(t)$. A light ray which is comming into tube from one end and bouncing with perfect reflection from the interior walls will emerge from the other end with probability 1; see [this question][1]. **Let us call a tube with this property an *optic fiber*.** One can construct an *optic fiber* along the same lines using any simple close smooth plane curve $(x(\theta),y(\theta))$ instead of circle. To do this one has to choose a parallel normal frame $e_1,e_2$ along $\gamma$ (i.e., such that $\dot e_i(t)\parallel\dot\gamma(t)$ for all $t$) and consider the tube $[a,b]\times\mathbb S^1\hookrightarrow\mathbb R^3$ defined as $$(t,\theta)\mapsto \gamma(t)+x(\theta){\cdot}e_1(t)+y(\theta){\cdot}e_2(t)$$ This way we get an *optic fiber* with congruent ends. >**Question 1.** Are there any constructions of *optic fibers* different from the one described above? In particular, >**Question 2.** Is there an *optic fiber* with noncongruent ends? **Comments** - I feel that the answer is "NO", but have no idea "WHY". - From Liouville's theorem, it is clear that the ends must have the same area. [1]: http://mathoverflow.net/questions/70421/light-rays-bouncing-in-twisted-tubes