Return to Revisions

Note that $n$ is the sum over prime divisors $p$ of $|G|$ of the minimal number of generators of the distinct Sylow $p$-subgroups of $G.$ The minimal number of generators of a finite $p$-group is well defined by properties of the Frattini subgroup. Use of the Frattini subgroup helps to prove the leftmost inequality: take a prime $p$ which divides $d_1 .$ Then a Sylow $p$-subgroup of $G$ can't be generated by fewer than $k$ elements, so $G$ itself certainly can't be generated by fewer than $k$ elements, as each Sylow $p$-subgroup of $G$ is a homomorphic image of $G.$ On the other hand, take a minimal generating set $S$ for $G$ of maximal cardinality. Then each element of $S$ must have prime power order, for if $s \in S$ has order divisible by more than one prime, then we may write $s = t + u $ where $t$ and $u$ have coprime orders (each greater than one) whose product is the order of $s$. Then $(S \backslash \{ s \}) \cup \{t,u\}$ is still a minimal generating set for $G$, contradicting the maximality of the cardinality of $S.$ The fact that $S$ is a minimal generating set means that if we now collect the elements of $S$ whose orders are powers of a fixed prime $p$, we must obtain a generating set for a Sylow $p$-subgroup of $G,$ and this must be minimal by the choice of $S$. Hence the cardinality of $S$ is at most $n,$ as defined above.