Skip to main content
4 of 4
streamlined answer on Lie derivatives and connections, to go along with proposed edit
user avatar
user avatar

The real motivation for the Lie derivative is doing differential calculus with vector fields. If we want fo differentiate the vector field $W$ in the direction of the vector field $V$, we take the flow of $V$ through time, use it to pull back $W$, and take the derivative at $t=0$.

To explain better, let $V$ and $W$ be vector fields on a smooth manifold $M$, with $\theta:M\times\mathbb R\supseteq\mathcal D\to M$ the flow of $V$. Because $\theta_t$ is a diffeomorphism from the set $\{p\in M| (t,p)\in \mathcal D\} := M_t$ to the set $M_{-t}$, with inverse $\theta_{-t}$, we can use it to pull back vector fields, as follows: define $(\theta_t^*W)_p$ by $$\theta{_{-t}*} W_{\theta_t(p)}\in T_pM.$$ We can then take the following limit$$\lim_{t\to 0}\frac{(\theta_t^*W)_p -W_p}t := \mathcal (L_VW)_p = \frac d{dt}\big |_{t= 0}(\theta_t^*W)_p$$ which we call the Lie derivative. It allows us to transport a vector field at one point to a vector at another, and find the rate of change of that transformation.

Why do we do this? Because it is a step towards generalizing analysis to an arbitrary smooth manifold. It allows us to take the derivative of a vector field "along" the flow of another.

However, there is a problem. Lie derivatives do not allow us to take directional derivatives along curves, as it leads to problems. This is why we use the notion of a connection.

(My source for the last comment is the following Math.SE question: Link. My main source generally is John Lee's Introduction to Smooth Manifolds.)