This post is a sequel to: [Collaboration or acknowledgment?][1] 

The following has come to my attention. A senior mathematician suggested a problem to a young mathematician who proceeded to solve it on his own. The senior mathematician signed the paper and included his PhD student as a coauthor because they were thinking about the same problem, despite the fact they did not even have partial results. Is there a way for the young mathematician to manage such a situation without creating conflict?  

**Edit:** Based on the discussion below my conclusion is that most people do not find this type of behaviour unethical. 

  [1]: https://mathoverflow.net/questions/191507/collaboration-or-acknowledgment