Skip to main content
1 of 4
archipelago
  • 3k
  • 21
  • 37

Repeating the first part of Oscar's answer and elaborating on comments by Chris and Panagiotis, here is a down-to-earth argument in all cases:

These cases $n=1,3,7$ are fine, since in these cases the stable stems are generated by $S^1$, $S^3$, $S^7$ with the unstable framing induced by the multiplication in the unit complex numbers, quaternions, or octonions.

In the other cases, we use that the obstruction to destabilising a given stable framing $F$ of an oriented closed manifold $M^n$ lies in $H^n(M,\pi_n(SO/SO(d))$, which is isomorphic (in a preferred way) to $\mathbb{Z}$ if $n$ is even and to $\mathbb{Z}/2$ if $n$ is odd. It is not too hard to see that, with respect to this isomorphism, the obstruction is given by the semi-characterstic: half the Euler characteristic for $n=2d$ and $\sum_{i=0}^d\mathrm{dim}(H_i(M,\mathbb{Z}/2))\text{ mod }(2)$ for $n=2d+1$ and $n\neq1,3,7$. In particular, the obstruction to destabilising is independent of $F$ which is somewhat surprising.

Originally this was proved by to Bredon and Kosinksi [1] who used a more geometric description of this obstruction: it is the degree (mod 2 if d is odd) of the Gauss map $M\rightarrow{S^n}$ induced by the stable framing $TM\oplus \varepsilon\cong \varepsilon^{n+1}$ (take the image of the canonical vector field in the trivial line bundle and normalize).

Now observe that by taking connected sums with $S^1\times S^{n-1}$ or $S^2\times S^{n-2}$ and extending the framing, any stably framed bordism class contains a representative with trivial semi-characteristic, so its stable framing can be destabilized.

[1] G.E. Bredon and A. Kosinski, Vector fields on $\pi$-manifolds. Annals of Math. 84, 85– 90 (1960).

archipelago
  • 3k
  • 21
  • 37