A year ago, I posted this problem on [MSE]. Now I have edit the following similar problem.(To adopt Hjalmar Rosengren suggestion) Which rarional values of $c$ and $d$,the numbers $\sin{(\pi\cdot c)},\sin{(\pi\cdot d)}$ and $1$ are linearly dependent over $Q$ **Question 1:** case 1: when $d=\dfrac{1}{18}$,How prove this $c=\dfrac{1}{18}?$ **Question 2** case 2: when $d\in Q$ give numbers,I guess also $c=d?$ because the case $d=0$ is known as [Niven's Theorem] [Niven's Theorem]:http://mathworld.wolfram.com/NivensTheorem.html