Skip to main content
1 of 2
YCor
  • 63.9k
  • 5
  • 187
  • 286

Inspired by McCool's paper given in Benjamin's answer, here's an explicit example that is finitely generated but not finitely presented:

let $\phi$ be an injective recursive function from positive integers to themselves, whose image is not recursive. Consider the group with recursive presentation $$G=\langle t,x\mid r_{\phi(n)}^{n!}:n\ge 1\rangle,\quad \text{where}\;r_m=[t^mxt^{-m},x].$$ It is not hard to check that $r_{\phi(n)}$ has order $n!$ and $r_m$ has infinite order if $m$ is not in the range of $\phi$. In particular, the infinite order problem (checking if an element has infinite order) is not solvable.

However this group has a solvable word problem. The idea is that given a word of length $n$, it is trivial in $G$ if and only if it is trivial in the partial presentation with only relators $r_{\phi(k)}^{k!}$ for $k\le n$, and word problem in these groups are (I think) simultaneously solvable although I haven't checked details.

Actually McCool says it's enough to embed such a group into a group with solvable word problem, no need to care that the image is recursive. And indeed that's enough (clearly solvability of the infinite order problem passes to finitely generated subgroups).

YCor
  • 63.9k
  • 5
  • 187
  • 286