If G is an affine algebraic group (for example a finite group), then the category of k-linear cocontinuous symmetric monoidal functors from Rep(G) to Vect_k is equivalent to the category of G-torsors over k. In particular, not every such functor needs to be isomorphic to the identity. For example, if k' is finite Galois extension of k with Galois group G, then the functor $F(V) = (V \otimes_{k} k')^{G}$ will satisfy all the axioms you will think to write down, but is not isomorphic to the identity functor.