Skip to main content
3 of 3
replaced http://mathoverflow.net/ with https://mathoverflow.net/

On sentences true in all finite groups (revisited)

Let $w$ be a group word with variables $\bar x, \bar y$, where $\bar x=(x_1,\dots ,x_m)$ and $\bar y=(y_1,\dots ,y_n).$ I am interested in the following questions.

(1) Is the sentence $(\forall\bar x)(\exists\bar y)w=1$ true in every group if it is true in every finite group?

(2) Is the sentence $(\exists\bar x)(\forall\bar y)w=1$ true in every group if it is true in every finite group?

For $m=2$ and $n=4$ the answer to (1) is negative, in general, as shown in T. Coulbois, A. Khelif, Proc. AMS 127 (1999), No. 4, 963--965.

In On sentences true in all finite groups I asked the questions (1) and (2) for $m=n=1$.

Bjørn Kjos-Hanssen gave positive answers to these questions. In fact, his answers can be generalized: an answer is positive for (1) if $m=1$, and for (2) if $n=1$. The open questions I want to ask:

(a) Is $(\forall xy)(\exists z)w(x,y,z)=1$ true in every group if it is true in every finite group?

(b) Is $(\exists x)(\forall yz)w(x,y,z)=1$ true in every group if it is true in every finite group?

owb
  • 893
  • 7
  • 16