Skip to main content
2 of 2
added 1071 characters in body; added 3 characters in body; added 47 characters in body
Will Sawin
  • 148.4k
  • 9
  • 324
  • 563

Edit: Per Tapio's answer, $1 \times 2 \times 3 \times ... \times n$ bricks always suffice, so $s(n)\leq \left(\begin{array}{c} n+1 \\ 2 \end{array}\right)$. Consider the lattice in $\mathbb Z^n$ defined by the equations $x_1 \equiv x_2$ mod $2$, $x_2 \equiv x_3$ mod $3$, ..., $x_{n-1} \equiv x_n$ mod $n$. Place a $1 \times 2 \times ... \times n$ bricks with one corner at each vertex of the lattice. This covers $\mathbb R^n$ because you first round $x_1$ down to the nearest integer, then $x_2$ down to the nearest multiple of two plus $x_1$, .... The second condition is clearly satisfied, since the distance between any two bricks is an integer. We only need to check the first. Equivalently, we check that there cannot be $n+2$ lattice points in a single brick of the same size. Proof: Suppose there were. Then two of them would have to have the same value of $x_n$ mod $n+1$. Since the $x_n$ values of those two points lie in an interval of length $n$, they must be the same. So they have the same value of $x_{n-1}$ mod $n$. By induction, they are identical.

Is this bound sharp? For $n=1$, this is clear. Here is a proof for $n=2$. Form a graph where the faces are bricks, the the edges are the boundaries of bricks, and the vertices are places where two bricks intersect. Suppose that no brick is a hexagon or larger. Then the number of edges in a large reason is no more than $5/2$ the number of faces, and the number of vertices is exactly $2/3$ the number of edges, so the Euler number is at least $F -5/2(1-2/3)F=F/6$ which is $O$ of the area of the region, where it should be $O$ of the boundary. Or "the graph is somewhere between a cube and a dodecahedron, but nowhere near an infinite plane"

Therefore, some face has at least 6 edges. Each edge has length and least $1$, since the two vertices can share at most two faces, so the other faces at each vertex are nonadjacent, so have distance at least $1$. Therefore the perimeter of some face is at least $6$. The perimeter of $[0,a]\times [0,b]$ is of course $2(a+b)$, so $s(2)\geq 3$. There is an explicit example with $s(T)=3$, so we are done.

Obviously parts of this argument generalize to higher dimensions, but it is not clear to me if one can patch up the other parts to make it usable.

Will Sawin
  • 148.4k
  • 9
  • 324
  • 563